What do you think?
Rate this book
Shadowfell #2
Raven Flight
Neryn has finally found the rebel group at Shadowfell, and now her task is to seek out the elusive Guardians, vital to her training as a Caller. These four powerful beings have been increasingly at odds with human kind, and Neryn must prove her worth to them. She desperately needs their help to use her gift without compromising herself or the cause of overthrowing the evil King Keldec.
Neryn must journey with the tough and steadfast Tali, who looks on Neryn's love for the double agent Flint as a needless vulnerability. And perhaps it is. What Flint learns from the king will change the battlefield entirely—but in whose favor, no one knows.
Neryn must journey with the tough and steadfast Tali, who looks on Neryn's love for the double agent Flint as a needless vulnerability. And perhaps it is. What Flint learns from the king will change the battlefield entirely—but in whose favor, no one knows.
416 pages, ebook
First published July 1, 2013
About the author
Juliet Marillier
79 books11.6k followersJuliet Marillier was born in Dunedin, New Zealand and grew up surrounded by Celtic music and stories. Her own Celtic-Gaelic roots inspired her to write her first series, the Sevenwaters Trilogy. Juliet was educated at the University of Otago, where she majored in music and languages, graduating BA and Bachelor of Music (Hons). Her lifelong interest in history, folklore and mythology has had a major influence on her writing.
Juliet is the author of twenty-one historical fantasy novels for adults and young adults, as well as a book of short fiction. Juliet's novels and short stories have won many awards.
Juliet lives in a 110 year old cottage in a riverside suburb of Perth, Western Australia. When not writing, she tends to her small pack of rescue dogs. She also has four adult children and eight grandchildren. Juliet is a member of the druid order OBOD (the Order of Bards, Ovates and Druids.)
Juliet is the author of twenty-one historical fantasy novels for adults and young adults, as well as a book of short fiction. Juliet's novels and short stories have won many awards.
Juliet lives in a 110 year old cottage in a riverside suburb of Perth, Western Australia. When not writing, she tends to her small pack of rescue dogs. She also has four adult children and eight grandchildren. Juliet is a member of the druid order OBOD (the Order of Bards, Ovates and Druids.)
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 640 reviews
March 21, 2018
Reviewed by: Rabid Reads
4.5 stars
I wasn’t very impressed with the first installment of this trilogy . . . But I’m a big enough Marillier fan, and I saw enough glimpses of the excellence I’ve come to expect from her that it wasn’t difficult to make myself continue with the series.
I am so glad.
RAVEN FLIGHT was everything I expected SHADOWFELL to be and then some. Ominous foreshadowings, beautifully imagined Fae creatures (and by “beautifully” I don’t mean pretty—I mean convincingly alien creatures to blow your friggin’ mind), the bittersweet longing of new love kept apart, heartbreaking but necessary truths learned by both the characters and the reader<------THIS is why Juliet Marillier will always have a spot on the bookshelf of my heart.
In RAVEN FLIGHT, we get to know some of the characters we’d barely met at the end of SHADOWFELL.
There are several types of stock female warrior characters. My first impression of Tali was that she was a female warrior of the hardass I-have-no-time-for-puny-nonwarrior-females-like-you-go-mend-something variety, and honestly, it took some time for that impression to be disproved.
When Regan tells Tali she's to guard Neryn on her quest to seek out the Guardians, Tali doesn’t handle it well . . .
She rants. She raves. She pleads. Only then does she comply, but she does not do it gracefully.
For the first part of their travels, they barely speak a word to each other (b/c sulking). BUT. Nothing brings people together like conflict (Just ask Harry, Ron, and Hermione).
Tali and Neryn are doing their stealthy travel thing when Tali leaves Neryn to fish or scout or something. So Neryn’s just chillin’ behind some scrub when she hears their predetermined warning signal, but instead of taking off on her own like she’s supposed to, she decides to investigate.
And a good thing she did, b/c Tali’s in a fight for her life, five-on-one, and she’s good, but nobody’s that good. Except Neryn isn’t as sneaky sneaky as she thinks she is, and pretty quickly she’s caught and used as a hostage against Tali—NOT good.
So what does Neryn do?
Uses her super Callerness, of course.
And what shows up to help?
Awesome river creature guy, that’s what.
But as fantastic as the description of this creature was, Marillier goes further to create a personality, an entity, with complex patterns of behavior.
Tali and Neryn get what information they can from the men, using River Creature to encourage when necessary. When they’ve learned everything of use, Neryn must decide what to do with them, and the ever helpful River Creature is happy to provide more options:
Coolest flippin’ Fae creature I’ve encountered in recent memory. And while this one is my favorite, it is only one of many.
So yeah . . . hard not to bond after that.
And then there’s the whole star-crossed lovers thing. You already know that I LOVE Flint. Well . . . so does Neryn. But they can’t be together, b/c . . . they just can’t. Not telling. But their love is so pure and so sweet and so absolutely delicious, that you can’t be upset about the lack of Flint in this installment, b/c the LONGING has taken hold of you, and you refuse to let it go. You cling to it, roll around in it, braid it into your hair and dance with it, and threaten anything that challenges it with torches and pitchforks.
Almost as fantastic as the LONGING, is the insight we get into Tali (I knew it, I KNEW IT).
When Neryn encounters the warrior ghosts for the second time, Tali is with her. Tali, being a warrior, herself, is of course going to be affected by the meeting. But it’s more than that, and, no, I can’t tell you why, just trust me—it is.
I did, however, have a couple of small issues. That thing that I knew about Tali? I’m pretty sure you’d figure it out too. It was kind of obvious in that the-lady-doth-protest-too-much way, but not only did Neryn not figure it out, she consciously states that she had no clue. None whatsoever.
Really? *frowns and squints*
My second (and bigger) issue, is that a fairly important character was killed off page. I hate that.
1. there’s no resolution, and
2. it’s lazy.
I don’t care if someone saw his head on a pike, if I don’t know, irrefutably, that a character is dead, I can’t let go. I keep expecting it to be a mistake, a misunderstanding, a LIE, and they’re going to turn up again any page now.
And that . . . is emotionally exhausting. And I’m already emotionally exhausted, b/c you killed someone important. So just stop it. THANKS.
But overall, RAVEN FLIGHT was an excellent book. So excellent that I have no qualms about making many friends and family members suffer through the first less-than-stellar installment to get to this one. If you still aren’t completely sold, have no fear—THE CALLER, the final installment of this trilogy will be available September 9. I’m off to read it right now, and I’ll be back to let you know how it goes. Count on it.
4.5 stars
I wasn’t very impressed with the first installment of this trilogy . . . But I’m a big enough Marillier fan, and I saw enough glimpses of the excellence I’ve come to expect from her that it wasn’t difficult to make myself continue with the series.
I am so glad.
RAVEN FLIGHT was everything I expected SHADOWFELL to be and then some. Ominous foreshadowings, beautifully imagined Fae creatures (and by “beautifully” I don’t mean pretty—I mean convincingly alien creatures to blow your friggin’ mind), the bittersweet longing of new love kept apart, heartbreaking but necessary truths learned by both the characters and the reader<------THIS is why Juliet Marillier will always have a spot on the bookshelf of my heart.
In RAVEN FLIGHT, we get to know some of the characters we’d barely met at the end of SHADOWFELL.
There are several types of stock female warrior characters. My first impression of Tali was that she was a female warrior of the hardass I-have-no-time-for-puny-nonwarrior-females-like-you-go-mend-something variety, and honestly, it took some time for that impression to be disproved.
When Regan tells Tali she's to guard Neryn on her quest to seek out the Guardians, Tali doesn’t handle it well . . .
She rants. She raves. She pleads. Only then does she comply, but she does not do it gracefully.
For the first part of their travels, they barely speak a word to each other (b/c sulking). BUT. Nothing brings people together like conflict (Just ask Harry, Ron, and Hermione).
Tali and Neryn are doing their stealthy travel thing when Tali leaves Neryn to fish or scout or something. So Neryn’s just chillin’ behind some scrub when she hears their predetermined warning signal, but instead of taking off on her own like she’s supposed to, she decides to investigate.
And a good thing she did, b/c Tali’s in a fight for her life, five-on-one, and she’s good, but nobody’s that good. Except Neryn isn’t as sneaky sneaky as she thinks she is, and pretty quickly she’s caught and used as a hostage against Tali—NOT good.
So what does Neryn do?
Uses her super Callerness, of course.
And what shows up to help?
Awesome river creature guy, that’s what.
Help us! Quickly, help!
The river roiled and rose up…
The water rose to my waist. A figure rose with it, taller than a tall man, a being all ripples and eddies and swirls, its features discernible as darker patches in the watery substance of its face. Flotsam adhered to its head, forming what might be hair or a hat, and within its body twigs and leaves washed about as if carried on the natural flow of the river. In its liquid face a mouth opened, a great dark cavity, and one of the men let out a terrified oath.
But as fantastic as the description of this creature was, Marillier goes further to create a personality, an entity, with complex patterns of behavior.
The river being spoke, its voice a thundering torrent of sound in which I sensed rather than heard words. “Wash, dip, splash, drown?”
Tali glanced at the eldritch creature, then quickly away. “Tell it not yet,” she said. “Not till they’ve answered some questions.”
“Wait, please,” I said, my teeth chattering . . .
Tali and Neryn get what information they can from the men, using River Creature to encourage when necessary. When they’ve learned everything of use, Neryn must decide what to do with them, and the ever helpful River Creature is happy to provide more options:
The river being held still, keeping the two suspended. So far as I could tell, it was looking at me. “Plunge, toss, drown, change?” it inquired
Coolest flippin’ Fae creature I’ve encountered in recent memory. And while this one is my favorite, it is only one of many.
So yeah . . . hard not to bond after that.
And then there’s the whole star-crossed lovers thing. You already know that I LOVE Flint. Well . . . so does Neryn. But they can’t be together, b/c . . . they just can’t. Not telling. But their love is so pure and so sweet and so absolutely delicious, that you can’t be upset about the lack of Flint in this installment, b/c the LONGING has taken hold of you, and you refuse to let it go. You cling to it, roll around in it, braid it into your hair and dance with it, and threaten anything that challenges it with torches and pitchforks.
Almost as fantastic as the LONGING, is the insight we get into Tali (I knew it, I KNEW IT).
When Neryn encounters the warrior ghosts for the second time, Tali is with her. Tali, being a warrior, herself, is of course going to be affected by the meeting. But it’s more than that, and, no, I can’t tell you why, just trust me—it is.
I did, however, have a couple of small issues. That thing that I knew about Tali? I’m pretty sure you’d figure it out too. It was kind of obvious in that the-lady-doth-protest-too-much way, but not only did Neryn not figure it out, she consciously states that she had no clue. None whatsoever.
Really? *frowns and squints*
My second (and bigger) issue, is that a fairly important character was killed off page. I hate that.
1. there’s no resolution, and
2. it’s lazy.
I don’t care if someone saw his head on a pike, if I don’t know, irrefutably, that a character is dead, I can’t let go. I keep expecting it to be a mistake, a misunderstanding, a LIE, and they’re going to turn up again any page now.
And that . . . is emotionally exhausting. And I’m already emotionally exhausted, b/c you killed someone important. So just stop it. THANKS.
But overall, RAVEN FLIGHT was an excellent book. So excellent that I have no qualms about making many friends and family members suffer through the first less-than-stellar installment to get to this one. If you still aren’t completely sold, have no fear—THE CALLER, the final installment of this trilogy will be available September 9. I’m off to read it right now, and I’ll be back to let you know how it goes. Count on it.
July 22, 2013
"Let there be a time in the future, I prayed, when he laughs with his children, and plays on the shore with them, and spends all his nights in loving arms. Let us have that. To whom I was praying I did not know. The future was in our own hands. If we wanted a world where such things were possible, it was for us to make it."I have read a number of sequels this year that have let me down. Second book syndrome, third book syndrome, you name it. Generally, if I like the first book in the series, the subsequent ones will be lacking in some sense. Usually the fault lies within characterization. The first book generally develops the character, and all the development stops as soon as the second book begins. A good plot is always more than welcome, but it takes a hell of a lot more than that to develop a good story. I have been a long-time fan of Juliet Marillier; she has always a masterful storyteller and writer, and I am pleased to say that this book is an excellent continuation of this series. I don't think I need to say much on the quality of her writing; if you have read any of her previous books, you will know that Juliet Marillier's writing is beautiful, evocative, while avoiding the trap of being Dickensianly verbose. Her dialogue is believable, her dialects beautifully done, and written so well that despite their pervasiveness, I have no cause for complaints.
Let me digress for a bit while we're on the topic of dialects; in a lot of romance novels involving Irish or Scottish characters, the local dialect is more often than not, intolerable. Laughable. A mockery. They're of the Willie-the-Groundskeeper bent, if you need a little The Simpsons reference in your day. Ach! Ye ken, lassie. Ah, dinna fash yerself, laddie., and so on, and so forth. More often than not, such portrayal of Celtic dialects have me wincing and wondering why the collective countries of Scotland and Ireland do not issue some sort of ultimatum to romance writers everywhere involving the portrayal of their people's speech.
While the dialect of the Little People, the Good Folk, the Fey Folk, whatever you want to call them, is almost aurally transcribed, it is so well-done and so consistently done, that I find no reason to roll my eyes at all. The speech, the accent, the distinctive ways of speaking all feels completely in tune with the book's setting and characters. For example:
"'Guards?' Steep spoke with derision. 'Ye mean them in the ha'? Just for show, they are, save for the Twa. The real fighters, we're a' doon below. We're the strong backbone o' this place; wi'oot the likes o' us, wha'd keep the Southies in check?'"Back to the meat of the book itself. This book is about learning, bravery, sacrifice. About overcoming your own principles and morals for the greater good. About surrending your own short-term wishes and dreams for the chance at a brighter future. About hope, about holding on to that hope when all seems lost. Lest I give the wrong impression about this book because of my high praises, this book is not saccharine sweet. There is no such thing as saccharine sweetness in a Juliet Marillier novel. The events in this book is harsh, unforgiving; life is difficult, people die, friends and strangers alike. There is no such thing as a "safe" character in this series. Beware to whom you get attached, because you might lose them. Still, life goes on, and the living must continue to live and fight and save the mourning for another day. There is no time for mourning, no time for weakness, because the enemy will use that weakness against you, given an iota of a chance.
This is not a standalone book, it is very much a continuation of a series, and while there is a small bit of summary of previous events, you will be hopelessly lost if you have not read the first book. In Raven Flight, Neryn continues her life with the rebel, but her training does not last long. As a Caller, her role is bigger than that. She has to seek and summon a number of Guardians, among them the Master of Shadows, the Hag of Isles, the Lord of the North. She has to travel quickly and lightly, so her sole bodyguard and companion is the imminently capable (albeit pricklier than a cactus), Tali. Along the way, they meet old friends, as well as the Good Folk, and encounter plenty of trouble along the way. The pacing is quick, the plot moves quickly and rationally. In other sequels, the action-packed plot still manage to bore me to tears because of the lack of character development. Not so here.
The most prominent characters in this book are the traveling companions of Neryn and Tali. Neryn is still weak, still overly soft. She is very human, despite what she has seen, despite what she has suffered, with high morals that bothered me at times. Neryn is powerful, but she is soft. She is reluctant to join the fight, even if she knows that's what is needed to win the war.
"It's going to be a long, hard fight, and people are going to die. You should know that, Neryn. What's needed here isn't soft dreams of true love. It’s anger—the anger that drives a person forward. The fury that keeps them fighting right up to the moment the knife goes in. In our world there's no place for love."Her rebel friends constantly remind her that she cannot afford such crises of conscience, that death is a necessity, that her gift is meant to be used, but Neryn is still frustratingly reluctant to use it, because she remembers how her power can kill as well. She has killed before, for the greater good; if she had not done what she did, even more rebel lives would have been lost, but Neryn is so stricken with her guilt that she can hardly bear to use her power of calling on the Good Folk in times of need.
"'Still weighed down by conscience? Even though what you did saved both our lives? Neryn, the rebellion depends on your gift. Without you, there's no chance we can do it in the time we have. You need to put these scruples behind you; if you can't, they'll become a burden too heavy for you to carry.'"In the previous book, we met the prickly, antagonistic, permanently angry Tali. I didn't like her very much at first then, but her character is built up so much more in this book. It seemed to be a bad idea to throw Tali and Neryn together at first, and I questioned Regan's decision of assigning her to be Neryn's guard...so did Tali. She has been training Neryn, but in her mind, Neryn is still a weak, incompetent girl, ill-equipped to do what she must do to save them all. Her first impression of Neryn is not a positive one, she thought Neryn was "a wee girl wandering where she didn't belong, trying to do a job that was far too big for her. A girl who hadn't the first idea what kind of life she'd need to live if she became one of Regan's Rebels."
Tali is still strong, but she shows her more vulnerable side as we get to know her, and I came to love her as a foil for the oftentimes weak, soft-hearted Neryn. Tali is straightforward, she speaks her mind, she takes no prisoners, there is no bullshitting her. She does not coddle Neryn at all, she cuts Neryn no slack for her physical and mental weakness, and she is exactly what Neryn needs. She became my favorite character in this book. Tali has feelings, she loves deeply, but she knows to keep her emotions under wraps, because that is just hoping for too much. All she can hope for day by day is survival. Anything else is just a pipe dream.
"I have no children. I never will. I have no husband, no lover, no family. Only fellow rebels, others like me. All of them understand how it has to be. Hard. Cruel. Brutal. Full of choices like the one Andra had to face. That makes it all the more vital to keep what we do under strict control."I have gone on for so long in this review, gushing about this book for a reason. Read this series. Read this book.
March 14, 2024
1.) Shadowfell ★★★★
Um, did that ending just happen?
Can I sue for emotional distress, because this book just sort of ruined me?
Well, before the heartbreak, this book starts off where Shadowfell left off; Neryn is at Shadowfell, but needs to leave to start seeking out the other three Guardians before the impending war.
She has already encountered the Master of Shadows (located in the south) in Shadowfell, but she still has the Hag of the Isles (located in the west), the Lord of the North (located north and unable to be awoken from his slumber), and the White Lady (located in the east), who seems the most elusive of the four.
Neryn not only needs to find these three Guardians, but they each have to teach her something that will help her in the final battle against the King and his Enforcers. Oh, and now they are on a deadline, so Neryn has to seek these three individuals out, in completely different and unknown locations, and receive their knowledge in a year and a half.
Needless to say, this book was filled with the same excitement and adventure that Shadowfell has. You will not feel second book syndrome with Raven Flight. Juliet Marillier is such an amazing storyteller, I was enchanted from page one and was unable to put this book down.
There is so much death foreshadowing, and actual death, in this book. I swear to God, if Neryn and Flint don't get their happily ever after after everything they have been through, especially Neryn and all her losses, I'm going to riot.
And Flint... Flint is my beautiful cinnamon roll that is too good for this world.
The other character I fell in love with while reading this book was Tali. We really get to see her character in this installment, and what a strong character she is. The friendship between her and Neryn warms my heart and Juliet Marillier does a wonderful job depicting that friendship grow and blossom, and grow believably and oh so beautifully.
And just in general, since Tali normally always takes some sort of leadership role in this book, I love how strong Juliet Marillier makes her female characters. The only thing I love more is how none of the main male characters have a problem with the women's' strength or leadership, but embrace it and never make it a competition. Hell, they even ask for advice and they never feel like it makes them less of a man. Like, it's never addressed. The equality is just expected. I can't even begin to tell you how rare and refreshing that is to read about.
I finished this in one day and I am so thankful that I have The Caller waiting for me. Honestly, I think I should just go buy all of Juliet Marillier back list, because I'm way too addicted to her writing. Like, this story is phenomenal, but the way she writes these characters and builds this world truly puts her in a league all by herself. I'm actually in awe and struggling to come up with cohesive sentences, because I'm so impressed with her and this book.
Um, did that ending just happen?
Can I sue for emotional distress, because this book just sort of ruined me?
Well, before the heartbreak, this book starts off where Shadowfell left off; Neryn is at Shadowfell, but needs to leave to start seeking out the other three Guardians before the impending war.
She has already encountered the Master of Shadows (located in the south) in Shadowfell, but she still has the Hag of the Isles (located in the west), the Lord of the North (located north and unable to be awoken from his slumber), and the White Lady (located in the east), who seems the most elusive of the four.
Neryn not only needs to find these three Guardians, but they each have to teach her something that will help her in the final battle against the King and his Enforcers. Oh, and now they are on a deadline, so Neryn has to seek these three individuals out, in completely different and unknown locations, and receive their knowledge in a year and a half.
Needless to say, this book was filled with the same excitement and adventure that Shadowfell has. You will not feel second book syndrome with Raven Flight. Juliet Marillier is such an amazing storyteller, I was enchanted from page one and was unable to put this book down.
“Let there be a time in the future, I prayed, when he laughs with his children, and plays on the shore with them, and spends all his nights in loving arms. Let us have that. To whom I was praying I did not know. The future was in our own hands. If we wanted a world where such things were possible, it was for us to make it.”
There is so much death foreshadowing, and actual death, in this book. I swear to God, if Neryn and Flint don't get their happily ever after after everything they have been through, especially Neryn and all her losses, I'm going to riot.
And Flint... Flint is my beautiful cinnamon roll that is too good for this world.
The other character I fell in love with while reading this book was Tali. We really get to see her character in this installment, and what a strong character she is. The friendship between her and Neryn warms my heart and Juliet Marillier does a wonderful job depicting that friendship grow and blossom, and grow believably and oh so beautifully.
And just in general, since Tali normally always takes some sort of leadership role in this book, I love how strong Juliet Marillier makes her female characters. The only thing I love more is how none of the main male characters have a problem with the women's' strength or leadership, but embrace it and never make it a competition. Hell, they even ask for advice and they never feel like it makes them less of a man. Like, it's never addressed. The equality is just expected. I can't even begin to tell you how rare and refreshing that is to read about.
I finished this in one day and I am so thankful that I have The Caller waiting for me. Honestly, I think I should just go buy all of Juliet Marillier back list, because I'm way too addicted to her writing. Like, this story is phenomenal, but the way she writes these characters and builds this world truly puts her in a league all by herself. I'm actually in awe and struggling to come up with cohesive sentences, because I'm so impressed with her and this book.
August 16, 2013
*waiting, waiting, having lots of anxiety attacks in the meantime*
EDIT: guys, July 9th!!!
EDIT 2: actual review to come
EDIT: guys, July 9th!!!
EDIT 2: actual review to come
May 11, 2020
This review was originally posted on Books of My Heart
Review copy was received from Publisher. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
Raven Flight is the second book of the Shadowfell series, recently released on audio. I liked the first book of the series Shadowfell enough to give the second book a try, plus I’ve loved most things I’ve read by Juliet Marillier so chances were high this book would work better for me and it did.
Neryn has figured out what she is and what part she will have to play in the upcoming war. She has found a home and people who care for her in the rebels. Neryn thinks about Flint often but knows that now is not the time for that dream.
Flint is a double agent close to the Evil King and the rebellions best source of information. He can’t be tied down by love just yet and if Neryn wants the hope of a life with Flint, she will need to learn how to control her gift and find four of the most powerful Fae in the North, South, East and West. So there is a bit of longing and pining but in a good I’m-not-tired-of-it-at-all kind of way.
Raven Flight worked better for me because Neryn is coming into her own. The set up has been made and this time around we get to see more of the kingdom but Neryn is stronger and surer of herself. She can fight, she can help to defend herself, she also doesn’t spend half the book ill. All big wins in my book.
I also enjoyed getting to meet two of the very different but equally powerful fae. The Hag of the Isles or as I like to think of her a Sea Witch and a Fae dude asleep for decades possibly centuries, I like to think of him as sleeping beauty but in a cold, stony kind of way. Neryn must learn both the ways of the water and the ways of stone from these two creatures as part of her journey to become a caller. She must learn to master it all in a very short period of time if the rebels are to have a chance and keep all of their forces intact.
I enjoyed this world, well at least the fae creatures we meet along the way. I enjoy hating the evil King and his equally evil Queen. They seem to be a match made in hell really and completely perfect for one another.
The story is much better. This is a slower moving young adult novel; it has the air of campfire story passed down through generations, the beginnings of a fairy tale to it. It does have some limitations as most of the story is through Neryn’s experiences with just a few snippets from Flint’s PoV. There was an important death off page that I wanted a little more closure on but other than that I really don’t have many complaints about this book in the series.
Narration:
Henrietta Meire has the perfect voice for this series. The slight accent she has works very well for some of the otherness of the series. I listened to this at my usual 1.5x speed.
Listen to a clip: HERE
Review copy was received from Publisher. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
Raven Flight is the second book of the Shadowfell series, recently released on audio. I liked the first book of the series Shadowfell enough to give the second book a try, plus I’ve loved most things I’ve read by Juliet Marillier so chances were high this book would work better for me and it did.
Neryn has figured out what she is and what part she will have to play in the upcoming war. She has found a home and people who care for her in the rebels. Neryn thinks about Flint often but knows that now is not the time for that dream.
Flint is a double agent close to the Evil King and the rebellions best source of information. He can’t be tied down by love just yet and if Neryn wants the hope of a life with Flint, she will need to learn how to control her gift and find four of the most powerful Fae in the North, South, East and West. So there is a bit of longing and pining but in a good I’m-not-tired-of-it-at-all kind of way.
Raven Flight worked better for me because Neryn is coming into her own. The set up has been made and this time around we get to see more of the kingdom but Neryn is stronger and surer of herself. She can fight, she can help to defend herself, she also doesn’t spend half the book ill. All big wins in my book.
I also enjoyed getting to meet two of the very different but equally powerful fae. The Hag of the Isles or as I like to think of her a Sea Witch and a Fae dude asleep for decades possibly centuries, I like to think of him as sleeping beauty but in a cold, stony kind of way. Neryn must learn both the ways of the water and the ways of stone from these two creatures as part of her journey to become a caller. She must learn to master it all in a very short period of time if the rebels are to have a chance and keep all of their forces intact.
I enjoyed this world, well at least the fae creatures we meet along the way. I enjoy hating the evil King and his equally evil Queen. They seem to be a match made in hell really and completely perfect for one another.
The story is much better. This is a slower moving young adult novel; it has the air of campfire story passed down through generations, the beginnings of a fairy tale to it. It does have some limitations as most of the story is through Neryn’s experiences with just a few snippets from Flint’s PoV. There was an important death off page that I wanted a little more closure on but other than that I really don’t have many complaints about this book in the series.
“Look forward, not back," the Hag said. "All is change. Do not regret. Instead, learn.”
“cherish what you have, for in an instant it can be gone. And when it’s gone, let the memory not be a weight that drags you down, but a bright light leading you forward.”
Narration:
Henrietta Meire has the perfect voice for this series. The slight accent she has works very well for some of the otherness of the series. I listened to this at my usual 1.5x speed.
Listen to a clip: HERE
February 28, 2021
I’m a huge fan of Juliet Marillier. I love her Celtic/Gaelic inflected epic fantasy with its deep dives into captivating characters, great storytelling, wonderful world building, magic and uncanny creatures, and heartfelt romance.
That said, this series and its characters have been growing on me slowly. I found this to be true in other series of hers that I’ve read. She slowly reveals characters and their backstories like layers of an onion.
I liked this book much better than the previous one, Shadowfell. I’ve been slow to warm to the heroine of this series, Neryn. She isn’t a badass like other Marillier heroines Blackthorn of the series Blackthorn and Grim and her warrior daughter Liobhan from The Harp of Kings . (Although of course it wouldn’t be Marillier without at least one badass woman, which in this series is the warrior Tali). Neryn is a softer type. She is quiet and humble and has strong intuitive links to nature and uncanny creatures. In the kingdom of evil King Keldec, anyone with uncanny powers is an outcast. But Neryn eventually finds her people and her footing.
I liked her better in this book than in the previous book in the series. We watch her grow, mature, and find her considerable strength.
I think part of the problem has been actress Henrietta Meire’s audio reading, which has also improved. In the first book she read Neryn as a shrill hysteric, often on the verge of panic. Although after all, Neryn is a teenager when we first encounter her in the previous book. And what teenage girl isn’t emotionally labile? I find Meire’s reading a touch too theatrical in places, but she’s improving as the series progresses.
The story telling is amazing here, both in plot and in the way the tale is told. Neryn goes on a quest to seek guidance from uncanny elders in using her awakening ability to communicate with the fey and other magical beings. The magical beings come to Neryn’s aid in wonderful ways.
Many of the secondary characters are compelling as well, including Tali and Flint, Neryn’s love.
A caveat to readers. Marillier’s storytelling, although very creative, is rooted in the traditional tales of Ireland, Scotland, etc. Those who require their fantasy to be hip, urban, modern, edgy, etc. won’t go for her slowly unfolding style of narration. For me, though, it’s just right.
That said, this series and its characters have been growing on me slowly. I found this to be true in other series of hers that I’ve read. She slowly reveals characters and their backstories like layers of an onion.
I liked this book much better than the previous one, Shadowfell. I’ve been slow to warm to the heroine of this series, Neryn. She isn’t a badass like other Marillier heroines Blackthorn of the series Blackthorn and Grim and her warrior daughter Liobhan from The Harp of Kings . (Although of course it wouldn’t be Marillier without at least one badass woman, which in this series is the warrior Tali). Neryn is a softer type. She is quiet and humble and has strong intuitive links to nature and uncanny creatures. In the kingdom of evil King Keldec, anyone with uncanny powers is an outcast. But Neryn eventually finds her people and her footing.
I liked her better in this book than in the previous book in the series. We watch her grow, mature, and find her considerable strength.
I think part of the problem has been actress Henrietta Meire’s audio reading, which has also improved. In the first book she read Neryn as a shrill hysteric, often on the verge of panic. Although after all, Neryn is a teenager when we first encounter her in the previous book. And what teenage girl isn’t emotionally labile? I find Meire’s reading a touch too theatrical in places, but she’s improving as the series progresses.
The story telling is amazing here, both in plot and in the way the tale is told. Neryn goes on a quest to seek guidance from uncanny elders in using her awakening ability to communicate with the fey and other magical beings. The magical beings come to Neryn’s aid in wonderful ways.
Many of the secondary characters are compelling as well, including Tali and Flint, Neryn’s love.
A caveat to readers. Marillier’s storytelling, although very creative, is rooted in the traditional tales of Ireland, Scotland, etc. Those who require their fantasy to be hip, urban, modern, edgy, etc. won’t go for her slowly unfolding style of narration. For me, though, it’s just right.
March 28, 2015
Dear Juliet,
I hope you don't mind me addressing you like this. I have been reding your books for more than ten years, so I feel like we have this kind of bond. Not quite like friends, something that can only exist between the writer and his/hers readers.
So, my dear Juliet, I have to ask you: what was this?!
I still remember a time when your books told breath-taking, adventurous, stories, with female characters full of courage, ready to sacrifice themselves for their families and their beliefs. I still remember devouring The Sevenwaters trilogy (when it was still a trilogy) and feeling swept away. That was some awesome fantasy! Then, of course, I had to read the Saga of the Light Isles, and I was sorry that the Bridei Chronicles were just a trilogy. Because I liked them that much! Even those two books, 'Wildwood Dancing' and 'Cybele's Secret', were really cool. And they were for young readers.
Then there was a decline. Come on, 'Heart's Blood' was nice, but nothing particularly great. And from the last three Sevenwaters books outside the trilogy, only 'Flame of Sevenwaters' seemed to have returned to old-time splendour.
This Shadowfell Series is disappointing me as I go on reading each book. The first one was ok, but this one was too boring. I can't bring myself to like Neryn, and her relationship with Flint is just eye-rolling. For me, the best about this Series is the Good Folk. They are the best characters you could have come across for these books. Maybe, Juliet my darling, you should have though of writing a series with otherworldly characters only. No complicated and lame human relationships. Just quirky and mysterious creatures going on, maybe, a great adventure.
But not all was bad in this book. It was very interesting to see more of Keldec, especially his relationship with Queen Varda. Who rules who? Everyone says that it is the King who's afraid of gifted subjects. But that Queen is clearly a very disturbed (and disturbing) woman.
Apart from this, and the presence of those funny Good Folk creatures, I can't point out more positive things. It was boring and very uninteresting. I don't think I will be reading the third book, 'The Caller'. I usually like to finish a series, since I started it, but it is high time that I stop doing that. It is enough that I finish the book. Besides, I don't feel like wasting money on something that's probably be a disappointment.
All this said, I must ask you if I should read 'Dreamer's Pool' from the new series. I am always curious about your books, Juliet, but I don't want to end up feeling disappointed as I had these past books. And trust me when I tell you that I waited a lot to be able to put my hands on Shadowfell.
So, I think I said what I had to say. Not all nice, but I firmly believe that some things are best not left unsaid. And I hope you keep on writing. I also hope I will read another great book from you in the future. Because I know you can. You have it inside of you.
Kind regards from a once-very-big-fan of yours,
Catarina
I hope you don't mind me addressing you like this. I have been reding your books for more than ten years, so I feel like we have this kind of bond. Not quite like friends, something that can only exist between the writer and his/hers readers.
So, my dear Juliet, I have to ask you: what was this?!
I still remember a time when your books told breath-taking, adventurous, stories, with female characters full of courage, ready to sacrifice themselves for their families and their beliefs. I still remember devouring The Sevenwaters trilogy (when it was still a trilogy) and feeling swept away. That was some awesome fantasy! Then, of course, I had to read the Saga of the Light Isles, and I was sorry that the Bridei Chronicles were just a trilogy. Because I liked them that much! Even those two books, 'Wildwood Dancing' and 'Cybele's Secret', were really cool. And they were for young readers.
Then there was a decline. Come on, 'Heart's Blood' was nice, but nothing particularly great. And from the last three Sevenwaters books outside the trilogy, only 'Flame of Sevenwaters' seemed to have returned to old-time splendour.
This Shadowfell Series is disappointing me as I go on reading each book. The first one was ok, but this one was too boring. I can't bring myself to like Neryn, and her relationship with Flint is just eye-rolling. For me, the best about this Series is the Good Folk. They are the best characters you could have come across for these books. Maybe, Juliet my darling, you should have though of writing a series with otherworldly characters only. No complicated and lame human relationships. Just quirky and mysterious creatures going on, maybe, a great adventure.
But not all was bad in this book. It was very interesting to see more of Keldec, especially his relationship with Queen Varda. Who rules who? Everyone says that it is the King who's afraid of gifted subjects. But that Queen is clearly a very disturbed (and disturbing) woman.
Apart from this, and the presence of those funny Good Folk creatures, I can't point out more positive things. It was boring and very uninteresting. I don't think I will be reading the third book, 'The Caller'. I usually like to finish a series, since I started it, but it is high time that I stop doing that. It is enough that I finish the book. Besides, I don't feel like wasting money on something that's probably be a disappointment.
All this said, I must ask you if I should read 'Dreamer's Pool' from the new series. I am always curious about your books, Juliet, but I don't want to end up feeling disappointed as I had these past books. And trust me when I tell you that I waited a lot to be able to put my hands on Shadowfell.
So, I think I said what I had to say. Not all nice, but I firmly believe that some things are best not left unsaid. And I hope you keep on writing. I also hope I will read another great book from you in the future. Because I know you can. You have it inside of you.
Kind regards from a once-very-big-fan of yours,
Catarina
December 22, 2015
[3.5 stars] Raven Flight follows Neryn and Tali as they venture across Alban to seek out the elusive Guardians that are essential in Neryn's training as a Caller. The unlikely duo are opposites, but both are admirable in their own right. Neryn has a sort of quiet strength about her, she never complains or whines when things get tough. Tali on the other hand is tough and outspoken. They are the epitome of strong female characters, and the blossoming friendship between the pair is beautiful.
However, having said all that I have to admit that I didn't really enjoy Raven Flight as much as I had hoped to. It was a slow-paced sequel, and I often found myself skimming over the descriptions. I didn't mind that the pacing of the first book was slow, but usually from a sequel I expect action.
Flint and Neryn both have separate duties that weigh heavily on them, and so conflict arises in their relationship. The two tread very different paths - as the Kings most trusted Enforcer Flint has to do what he can to avoid arousing suspicion and prove that he's loyal. Neryn on the other hand must travel across Alban to seek out the Guardians, while at the same time avoid being captured by the Enforcers. Being together is dangerous as they can be used against each other, and this of course cannot happen as they both play an important role in freeing Alban from the grips of the King. Although they are apart for most of the book, Flint and Neryn do share some sweet moments when they briefly meet.
It was towards the end where things really started to picked up, and I became truly engaged. The last quarter of the book really packed a punch, and I hope that this sudden appearance of heart stopping revelations and excitement carries over to book 3.
Despite not loving Raven Flight as much as Shadowfell I will still be picking up the final book in the trilogy when it's released.
This review also appears on my blog, The Page Turner.
However, having said all that I have to admit that I didn't really enjoy Raven Flight as much as I had hoped to. It was a slow-paced sequel, and I often found myself skimming over the descriptions. I didn't mind that the pacing of the first book was slow, but usually from a sequel I expect action.
Flint and Neryn both have separate duties that weigh heavily on them, and so conflict arises in their relationship. The two tread very different paths - as the Kings most trusted Enforcer Flint has to do what he can to avoid arousing suspicion and prove that he's loyal. Neryn on the other hand must travel across Alban to seek out the Guardians, while at the same time avoid being captured by the Enforcers. Being together is dangerous as they can be used against each other, and this of course cannot happen as they both play an important role in freeing Alban from the grips of the King. Although they are apart for most of the book, Flint and Neryn do share some sweet moments when they briefly meet.
It was towards the end where things really started to picked up, and I became truly engaged. The last quarter of the book really packed a punch, and I hope that this sudden appearance of heart stopping revelations and excitement carries over to book 3.
Despite not loving Raven Flight as much as Shadowfell I will still be picking up the final book in the trilogy when it's released.
This review also appears on my blog, The Page Turner.
November 16, 2016
I quite enjoyed the first book in the series but this one lacked a bit of the spark that the first one had. I can't put my finger on exactly what it was, but there was just some oomph missing. I did still very much enjoy this book though, it was just a bit of a slower read for me. I really enjoyed the progression of the story and seeing Neryn explore and learn about her gift. I also thought the character growth from the first book to this one was excellent! I loved seeing how they changed and grew through their experiences. I also may have shed a tear or two towards the end, I was just not expecting that twist! All in all, I loved this book despite finding it a bit slower and can't wait to get started on the third in the series!
August 4, 2018
"Não era um chamamento o que a situação exigia, mas sim um ritual! Ou, pelo menos. uma prece: o reconhecimento de que o meu dom dependia do poder de Alban, dos seus lagos, montanhas e florestas, das suas grutas, cumes de colinas e lugares sagrados. A magia de uma Voz residia não nela mesma mas no mundo natural; a Voz tinha que aprender a deixar essa magia fluir através dela."
May 30, 2017
Second books are always hard for me. I just have issues with series, the second book always feels like more of a time filler. This one felt like that for a minute but that might have just been my attitude. The beginning could have been shortened a bit, but I enjoyed it. Marillier is such a good storyteller that it is hard to fault her movement. More journeying for Neryn and her band. More danger and learning. This book had more of a different feel then the first. The first book was so much sadness and desperation, you can feel the hope in this one. This of course has more violence then the first book. We get more of a closer look at this crazy psycho king and his torture of his people. There are some intense scenes of violence and torture. They are kept to a Young Adult feel. There is a couple attempted rapes that are all talk but are stopped. And there is a intimate scene that is sensual and a little much for a YA book. This would be a PG13 movie for those that need that info before handing it to a teen.
December 7, 2014
August 2014 Re-read: Just as good as last time. I'm so freaking invested in these characters and this world. Gah! I need the next book! Thank goodness I finally have it.
Be warned, spoilers for Shadowfell abound below.
Map of Alban from Juliet Marillier's website
Last year I read my very first Juliet Marillier book, Shadowfell. It was one of my favorite books of the year and single-handedly saved the YA genre for me. Immersive, smart, peopled with characters I cared about – it drew me in and kept me wanting more. I was more than a little nervous when I picked up Raven Flight; sequels have let me down more often than they’ve impressed me.
I ended up loving it even more than the first book in the series, and my excitement for the concluding volume in the trilogy is through the roof!
In Shadowfell Neryn had a goal, just reach the end and all would be alright. She learned a bit differently on her journey, but it was still that singular goal. Raven Flight has Neryn on another journey, this time to hone her craft, learn the skill of a Caller, and be the person who is needed to turn the tide in the war to come against the King.
She is still incredibly reluctant to use the gifts that can cause death and injury to those around her, she feels guilt for those she hurts and those that die. That showed, to me, that she’s conscientious. If those that have the power to harm never consider, worry over, or rail against the consequences, I worry about them being in power. As she journeys to the Guardians part of what I saw in her training was the knowledge and learning to be able to instinctively use her gift in ways that do the most good.
As the journey once again takes a large part of the story, with no small amount of time spent in her lessons, we’re cut off from the greater group of people within Alban. Neryn travels, mostly, only with Tali - her guard. We get some incredibly important glimpses, small moments that are all the more precious, to us and Neryn, because of their brevity, but for the most part this book is the building of Neryn. I have to say, I appreciated this more than nearly anything in the book. Too often in books I’ve read the woman will have some special gift, powerful and demanding, and then she meets a man and becomes dependent on him for the rest of the story. Not so with Neryn. Her thoughts wander to Flint with regularity, but he’s off doing what he must do while she travels with a woman who soon becomes a friend.
I didn’t like Tali much when we first met her. She was brash with little depth, I thought. I was wrong. Tali has layers that haven’t even begun to be shown. She’s steadfast and strong, confident and still slightly vulnerable, loyal and a good friend. Watching the true friendship develop between these two was so incredibly refreshing.
Flint, oh Flint. I love your tortured soul more with each and every word. Those small glimpses from your point of view were cherished; over too quickly, but all the more special and important because of it. I can’t get enough of this man that walks on both sides of the war and the sacrifices he has to make. The tenderness in his heart, after all he’s done, is amazing and incredible. My heart breaks for him frequently. I worry about him all the time. Sooner or later his secret will be out, I only hope he’s prepared. The moments between Flint and Neryn were heart-wrenching and oh-so sweet. I need more.
In Shadowfell the villain, the King, was little more than a reference. We saw the consequences and actions of his decrees, but none of him. Not so here! We finally get more than a vague reference to the King’s villainy; and it was enough to make me wish I could jump into the book and get rid of him myself!
I should talk about the Good Folk for a moment, or their dialect. I am a reader that, generally, hates written dialect. It’s often distracting and hard to read, not to mention often used incorrectly and stereotypically. While the Good Folk do talk in dialect, and a fairly strong one, it’s very nearly phonetic, easy to read, easy to understand, and completely consistent. It adds depth and something more to both the characters and the world that they’ve lived in for so long. This is one of the few books where I really appreciate the dialect added to their speech.
There’s not a lot more I can say without spoiling a whole lot of the book, but I will say that even with the slightly slower pace than Shadowfell, this book put me through the emotional wringer. There isn’t a character in the entire rebel force, or of the Good Folk that I’m not attached to, all of them are special and distinct.
I said, when I finished, that I wasn’t sure what I was going to do with the long year (or so) wait until Caller, the third and final book in this series, comes out. A friend said: “Oh, that's simple. You start her other books.” Lucky for me I haven’t yet dug into Juliet Marillier’s back-list. But I shall, oh yes, I will.
Be warned, spoilers for Shadowfell abound below.
Map of Alban from Juliet Marillier's website
Last year I read my very first Juliet Marillier book, Shadowfell. It was one of my favorite books of the year and single-handedly saved the YA genre for me. Immersive, smart, peopled with characters I cared about – it drew me in and kept me wanting more. I was more than a little nervous when I picked up Raven Flight; sequels have let me down more often than they’ve impressed me.
I ended up loving it even more than the first book in the series, and my excitement for the concluding volume in the trilogy is through the roof!
But some things did not change...Courage, for instance. Dedication to a cause. Comradeship. When they were strong and pure, when they came from deep in the bone, those qualities could hold fast against all odds.
In Shadowfell Neryn had a goal, just reach the end and all would be alright. She learned a bit differently on her journey, but it was still that singular goal. Raven Flight has Neryn on another journey, this time to hone her craft, learn the skill of a Caller, and be the person who is needed to turn the tide in the war to come against the King.
She is still incredibly reluctant to use the gifts that can cause death and injury to those around her, she feels guilt for those she hurts and those that die. That showed, to me, that she’s conscientious. If those that have the power to harm never consider, worry over, or rail against the consequences, I worry about them being in power. As she journeys to the Guardians part of what I saw in her training was the knowledge and learning to be able to instinctively use her gift in ways that do the most good.
“I like your anger…I like your resistance. It makes you less than courteous, but altogether more interesting.”
As the journey once again takes a large part of the story, with no small amount of time spent in her lessons, we’re cut off from the greater group of people within Alban. Neryn travels, mostly, only with Tali - her guard. We get some incredibly important glimpses, small moments that are all the more precious, to us and Neryn, because of their brevity, but for the most part this book is the building of Neryn. I have to say, I appreciated this more than nearly anything in the book. Too often in books I’ve read the woman will have some special gift, powerful and demanding, and then she meets a man and becomes dependent on him for the rest of the story. Not so with Neryn. Her thoughts wander to Flint with regularity, but he’s off doing what he must do while she travels with a woman who soon becomes a friend.
I didn’t like Tali much when we first met her. She was brash with little depth, I thought. I was wrong. Tali has layers that haven’t even begun to be shown. She’s steadfast and strong, confident and still slightly vulnerable, loyal and a good friend. Watching the true friendship develop between these two was so incredibly refreshing.
Let there be a time in the future, I prayed, when he laughs with his children, and plays on the shore with them, and spends all his nights in loving arms. Let us have that. To whom I was praying I did not know. The future was in our own hands. If we wanted a world where such things were possible, it was for us to make it.
Flint, oh Flint. I love your tortured soul more with each and every word. Those small glimpses from your point of view were cherished; over too quickly, but all the more special and important because of it. I can’t get enough of this man that walks on both sides of the war and the sacrifices he has to make. The tenderness in his heart, after all he’s done, is amazing and incredible. My heart breaks for him frequently. I worry about him all the time. Sooner or later his secret will be out, I only hope he’s prepared. The moments between Flint and Neryn were heart-wrenching and oh-so sweet. I need more.
”There's a light shining in him, moving him forward: the light of freedom. That's what draws all of us to follow, to take risks, to keep on fighting when we see our comrades fall beside us. But there's no light without shadow.”
In Shadowfell the villain, the King, was little more than a reference. We saw the consequences and actions of his decrees, but none of him. Not so here! We finally get more than a vague reference to the King’s villainy; and it was enough to make me wish I could jump into the book and get rid of him myself!
I should talk about the Good Folk for a moment, or their dialect. I am a reader that, generally, hates written dialect. It’s often distracting and hard to read, not to mention often used incorrectly and stereotypically. While the Good Folk do talk in dialect, and a fairly strong one, it’s very nearly phonetic, easy to read, easy to understand, and completely consistent. It adds depth and something more to both the characters and the world that they’ve lived in for so long. This is one of the few books where I really appreciate the dialect added to their speech.
There’s not a lot more I can say without spoiling a whole lot of the book, but I will say that even with the slightly slower pace than Shadowfell, this book put me through the emotional wringer. There isn’t a character in the entire rebel force, or of the Good Folk that I’m not attached to, all of them are special and distinct.
I said, when I finished, that I wasn’t sure what I was going to do with the long year (or so) wait until Caller, the third and final book in this series, comes out. A friend said: “Oh, that's simple. You start her other books.” Lucky for me I haven’t yet dug into Juliet Marillier’s back-list. But I shall, oh yes, I will.
December 27, 2020
This book takes us into the heart and meat of the story. I loved all the different fae folk and really enjoyed the progression of friendship between Tali and Neryn. Things have changed dramatically for the Rebellion by the end of the book and time is not their friend in terms of fulfilling their plans. I loved everything about this book and am excited to be on to the culmination of the story.
July 22, 2013
Juliet Marillier is one of my all-time favourite authors and a new book from her is always reason to celebrate. So when Raven Flight appeared in my mailbox, I gave a little jump of joy and read it straightaway. Raven Flight is Book 2 in the Shadowfell series. I loved Shadowfell and it made my List of Best Books 2012 - the books are classic old-fashioned high fantasy with a quest at its heart. The writing is beautiful and limpid, the setting is an otherworldy Scotland, and the story mixes danger, magic and romance - sigh! I loved it. This is YA fantasy at its absolute best.
April 22, 2022
I really appreciate the way the story flows and the characters evolve.
This second part of the trilogy continues to build word after beautiful word and has the taste of a timeless story.
I really like the loph in which the female characters are written.
I declare myself madly in love with this world.
To the third part.
This second part of the trilogy continues to build word after beautiful word and has the taste of a timeless story.
I really like the loph in which the female characters are written.
I declare myself madly in love with this world.
To the third part.
July 4, 2018
“Cherish what you have, for in an instant it can be gone. And when it’s gone, let the memory not be a weight that drags you down, but a bright light leading you forward.”
July 5, 2013
There is a long winter to be spent at Shadowfell for Neryn to figure out who she will be to the people there and their rebellion. A long winter to become something more than the waif of a girl she arrived as and bring the Good Folk to Regan’s cause. A long winter followed by a very short few seasons in which Neryn must travel to the far reaches of her land to gain the training necessary to succeed as a Caller.
If I was disappointed in the first installment of Shadowfell, I can no longer say it was a result of reading it at the same time of one of Marillier’s superior novels. In fact, I haven’t read another Marillier since finishing Shadowfell, and I still found myself let down by the story therein. I had so dearly hoped that the fledgling confidence I held in Neryn at the end of Shadowfell would bloom into a full-throttled love in Raven Flight, but of course falilng in love isn’t that easy. It finally struck me that my continued grating with Neryn isn’t because of her faults, it is because of her lack thereof. She is, quite frankly, a bit of a Mary Sue. She’s a chosen one, and though inexpert in the use of her power is unfailingly kind, thoughtful, and generous to those around her. I do appreciate the internal struggles Neryn goes through with the thoughts of using her gift, but I, like Tali, get so utterly fed up with her being so unwilling to cause harm to anyone that she would instead stand aside and let Kaldec trample over scads of innocent souls.
As Flint was Neryn’s balance in book one, here Tali–the canny woman warrior from Shadowfell–provides us with a foil for our heroine and makes the story of Raven Flight one I was able to get into. Tali comes with a harder mind and a sharper edge, very willing to remind Neryn of the power a Caller holds. It is she that becomes Neryn’s prime companion for this story, and through her that we see the more subtle truths of rebellion. By Raven Flight’s close, there is no longer a question as to whether love makes us weak, or gives us hope.
Again we are given the very smallest snippets of the story from Flint’s point of view, and quite frankly, it was not enough for me. Not enough Flint period. Marillier cleverly steps back from the slow-burn relationship she wrought for us in the pages of Shadowfell, making Flint’s presence more brief and desperate in book two. I may whine for wanting more Flint, but in this way Marillier keeps us, and Neryn, from taking his position among the rebels for granted and reminds us consistently of the deadly game at which he plays. The scenes between Neryn and Flint here are so fleeting and urgent, filled with a longing for things they cannot show or do not yet have, and they did very successfully make me ache for more.
What made Raven Flight a stronger installment in this series, for me, was not only the emergence of Neryn as a strong-willed (if too-perfect) character of great endurance, but moreover the plot in which she and Tali journey to obtain her training from the Big Ones. I greatly enjoyed the further understanding of the relationship between Good Folk and humankind, and of Neryn’s power to bring them together. The trials she endures make Raven Flight more fairy-tale esque, and I very much enjoyed the imagery Marillier constructed throughout these sequences. That said, the chapters preceding this journey dragged for me. I found this book quite difficult to get into before finally some action broke and I was able to take in the last 80% or so in two long gulps.
I continue to wish this series were written in third person as my dislike of Neryn makes it difficult to enjoy this story directly through her interpretation, but I do feel as if this installment was stronger plot-wise than the first. The plot is becoming more complex, and while it tips its hat to many traditions of folklore or rebellion, it weaves the threads cleverly to create a unique but traditional fantasy. I missed the tension between Flint and Neryn that had crested by Shadowfell‘s close, but I also recognize the impossibility of continuing this slow-burn in the same way, and tip my hat to Marillier for inserting Tali in the begrudging friend slot to fill Flint’s place. Raven Flight was a story of friendship, love, survival, and most of all hope; I will certainly be there to cheer on Regan’s rebels in pages to come.
Review originally posted at Bunbury in the Stacks.
If I was disappointed in the first installment of Shadowfell, I can no longer say it was a result of reading it at the same time of one of Marillier’s superior novels. In fact, I haven’t read another Marillier since finishing Shadowfell, and I still found myself let down by the story therein. I had so dearly hoped that the fledgling confidence I held in Neryn at the end of Shadowfell would bloom into a full-throttled love in Raven Flight, but of course falilng in love isn’t that easy. It finally struck me that my continued grating with Neryn isn’t because of her faults, it is because of her lack thereof. She is, quite frankly, a bit of a Mary Sue. She’s a chosen one, and though inexpert in the use of her power is unfailingly kind, thoughtful, and generous to those around her. I do appreciate the internal struggles Neryn goes through with the thoughts of using her gift, but I, like Tali, get so utterly fed up with her being so unwilling to cause harm to anyone that she would instead stand aside and let Kaldec trample over scads of innocent souls.
As Flint was Neryn’s balance in book one, here Tali–the canny woman warrior from Shadowfell–provides us with a foil for our heroine and makes the story of Raven Flight one I was able to get into. Tali comes with a harder mind and a sharper edge, very willing to remind Neryn of the power a Caller holds. It is she that becomes Neryn’s prime companion for this story, and through her that we see the more subtle truths of rebellion. By Raven Flight’s close, there is no longer a question as to whether love makes us weak, or gives us hope.
Again we are given the very smallest snippets of the story from Flint’s point of view, and quite frankly, it was not enough for me. Not enough Flint period. Marillier cleverly steps back from the slow-burn relationship she wrought for us in the pages of Shadowfell, making Flint’s presence more brief and desperate in book two. I may whine for wanting more Flint, but in this way Marillier keeps us, and Neryn, from taking his position among the rebels for granted and reminds us consistently of the deadly game at which he plays. The scenes between Neryn and Flint here are so fleeting and urgent, filled with a longing for things they cannot show or do not yet have, and they did very successfully make me ache for more.
What made Raven Flight a stronger installment in this series, for me, was not only the emergence of Neryn as a strong-willed (if too-perfect) character of great endurance, but moreover the plot in which she and Tali journey to obtain her training from the Big Ones. I greatly enjoyed the further understanding of the relationship between Good Folk and humankind, and of Neryn’s power to bring them together. The trials she endures make Raven Flight more fairy-tale esque, and I very much enjoyed the imagery Marillier constructed throughout these sequences. That said, the chapters preceding this journey dragged for me. I found this book quite difficult to get into before finally some action broke and I was able to take in the last 80% or so in two long gulps.
I continue to wish this series were written in third person as my dislike of Neryn makes it difficult to enjoy this story directly through her interpretation, but I do feel as if this installment was stronger plot-wise than the first. The plot is becoming more complex, and while it tips its hat to many traditions of folklore or rebellion, it weaves the threads cleverly to create a unique but traditional fantasy. I missed the tension between Flint and Neryn that had crested by Shadowfell‘s close, but I also recognize the impossibility of continuing this slow-burn in the same way, and tip my hat to Marillier for inserting Tali in the begrudging friend slot to fill Flint’s place. Raven Flight was a story of friendship, love, survival, and most of all hope; I will certainly be there to cheer on Regan’s rebels in pages to come.
Review originally posted at Bunbury in the Stacks.
April 2, 2016
Raven Flight was a disappointment, there was minimum action, the plot was very-slow paced and unnecessarily repetitive, there was too much telling and little showing, serious issues were being resolved too easily, and Neryn’s training was a farce.
Neryn wasn’t a strong enough character with exciting enough adventures to carry this book on her own. She is in constant need of help and carrying, her overwhelming angst over killing was annoying and hypocritical, she’s joined the rebellion for God's sake, and her achievements failed to impress me. Neryn is more of a Mary Sue in this book; she is the center of the story's universe because the author tells us so through the subsidiary characters cheering ordinary or even stupid actions.
Since book one I’d hoped we’d get to spend more time with Flint and Raven Flight’s blurb seemed to suggest we'd get more from his point-of-view, but even though that happens, it can't be for more than 20 pages total, which is a shame! Flint is such a deep and complex character with such potential for character and plot development. Experiencing events from his point-of-view would be both exhilarating and informative. It would give the reader a chance to experience events from the perspective of the King’s and his followers and a front-row seat to Flint’s dangerous life as a spy.
The romance wasn’t as compelling as in the first book either. The dialogue between them was cringe worthy at times and there wasn’t enough nurturing to make the level of intensity of their feelings convincing, especially since Neryn is constantly proving she lacks faith in Flint.
Neryn wasn’t a strong enough character with exciting enough adventures to carry this book on her own. She is in constant need of help and carrying, her overwhelming angst over killing was annoying and hypocritical, she’s joined the rebellion for God's sake, and her achievements failed to impress me. Neryn is more of a Mary Sue in this book; she is the center of the story's universe because the author tells us so through the subsidiary characters cheering ordinary or even stupid actions.
Since book one I’d hoped we’d get to spend more time with Flint and Raven Flight’s blurb seemed to suggest we'd get more from his point-of-view, but even though that happens, it can't be for more than 20 pages total, which is a shame! Flint is such a deep and complex character with such potential for character and plot development. Experiencing events from his point-of-view would be both exhilarating and informative. It would give the reader a chance to experience events from the perspective of the King’s and his followers and a front-row seat to Flint’s dangerous life as a spy.
The romance wasn’t as compelling as in the first book either. The dialogue between them was cringe worthy at times and there wasn’t enough nurturing to make the level of intensity of their feelings convincing, especially since Neryn is constantly proving she lacks faith in Flint.
July 4, 2018
(review in English below)
3,5*
A escrita da Juliet continua maravilhosa, mas só nas últimas 140 páginas conseguiu agarrar-me a sério. O facto de Flint quase não aparecer neste livro foi uma questão importante, pois é a personagem mais interessante desta história.
Surpreendeu-me bastante o nível de violência e crueldade de algumas cenas que a autora incluiu neste segundo volume da trilogia, sobretudo tendo em conta que é supostamente dirigida a um público mais jovem. Mas, pensando bem, depois de ter visto Os Jogos da Fome não devia estranhar...
A ver o que me reserva o último volume...
3.5 stars
Juliet's writing is always wonderful but this book only grabbed me in the last 140 pages. That Flint was almost absent was an important issue, as he's the most interesting character in this story.
I was rather surprised with all the violence and the cruelty of some scenes included in this second installment of the trilogy, especially when you think that it's supposedly meant for younger readers. But after seeing The Hunger Games movies, it's not that strange...
Let's see what's in store for me in book 3...
3,5*
A escrita da Juliet continua maravilhosa, mas só nas últimas 140 páginas conseguiu agarrar-me a sério. O facto de Flint quase não aparecer neste livro foi uma questão importante, pois é a personagem mais interessante desta história.
Surpreendeu-me bastante o nível de violência e crueldade de algumas cenas que a autora incluiu neste segundo volume da trilogia, sobretudo tendo em conta que é supostamente dirigida a um público mais jovem. Mas, pensando bem, depois de ter visto Os Jogos da Fome não devia estranhar...
A ver o que me reserva o último volume...
3.5 stars
Juliet's writing is always wonderful but this book only grabbed me in the last 140 pages. That Flint was almost absent was an important issue, as he's the most interesting character in this story.
I was rather surprised with all the violence and the cruelty of some scenes included in this second installment of the trilogy, especially when you think that it's supposedly meant for younger readers. But after seeing The Hunger Games movies, it's not that strange...
Let's see what's in store for me in book 3...
July 21, 2015
This is an incredible book. I have no words but those to say. Juliet Marillier always entertains, evokes emotion and delights her readers. There is no second book woes here. In fact, I think I like this one better than the first one. The first one built a perfectly wonderful world, but Raven Flight added so much more to the world. I have been raving to anyone who will listen about this author since I picked up Daughter of the Forest by accident at the library. I very rarely make purchases of books on the release day, but Marillier's books are one of the exceptions. She continually works her magic with her amazing world building and incredible characters. My only complaint is that there is too much of the journey motif in both books. I was glad when .
And she makes you think. What are the consequences in war? How responsible are the leaders when sending troops into battle? Neryn wrestles with this. I love how Marillier has depicted her journey as she tries to answer these questions.
I am starting right away on the next book. Love this series!
And she makes you think. What are the consequences in war? How responsible are the leaders when sending troops into battle? Neryn wrestles with this. I love how Marillier has depicted her journey as she tries to answer these questions.
I am starting right away on the next book. Love this series!
September 12, 2014
3.5 stars. I love Juliet Marillier, and have read all her books. I appreciate how she writes fantasy, but includes real issues and real emotions. I also like the fact that she always creates strong female characters, unlike many other fantasy books. Although I really enjoyed this book, I thought it was not as strong as the first in the series. I can't wait for the final installment coming early 2014.
October 27, 2022
I think one of my favorite aspects of Juliet Marilliers main characters is the subtle strength displayed. Something soft and firm that you wouldn't expect, but it is discovered during trying times. The fluidity and beauty if her writing always leaves me feeling warm and immersed in the world, emotions raw and holding hope between my hands.
August 5, 2017
по-прежнему не уверена, могу ли я ее рекомендовать - очень уж не our usual stuff, но такое удовольствие получаю.
November 21, 2013
Recordo bem que para mim, que nunca tinha tido o prazer de ler Juliet Marillier, Shadowfell foi como o abrir de uma janela para um novo mundo, um mundo onde reinava a beleza da simplicidade, onde a bondade se encontrava a florescer timidamente mas com raízes fortes entre o mal e onde a partilha era exposta como lição primordial, numa terra consumida, mirrada pelo egoísmo do seu rei. Agora, finda a leitura de O Voo do Corvo e após ter tido a oportunidade de conversar com a autora, a sua história e os desígnios dos seus intervenientes alcançaram uma nova consistência, uma nova dimensão em que a aprendizagem ficcional se mescla com o real de forma palpável, através de uma aventura épica com valores contemporâneos onde a essência da fantasia brota ao longo de todas as páginas.
Doravante as minhas palavras pecam por se dirigirem apenas aos leitores que leram o primeiro livro da trilogia da Shadowfell pois, tal como fica claro na sinopse, há o risco de spoilers.
Esta narrativa retoma o texto onde terminou o seu antecedente, com chegada de Neryn à fortaleza dos rebeldes que tanto se esforçou para alcançar, Shadowfell.
Depois da sua imensa caminhada, repleta de perigos mas também de conhecimento e amadurecimento - em que teve oportunidade de criar laços com os Boa Gente -, a protagonista deste enredo encontra-se agora entre aqueles que procuram banir o verdadeiro mal do Reino de Alban, muitas vezes sacrificando sentimentos em prol da vingança pelas suas perdas irreparáveis, lutando pela Causa que acreditam ser justa aos tempos cruéis em que tentam sobreviver.
É certo que passado doloroso jamais será esquecido e que o presente se adivinha mais arriscado que nunca, mas existe uma batalha para organizar da qual dependerá o futuro de todos e todos, por sua vez, dependem das conquistas da Voz. Este é, portanto, um livro em que Neryn terá que dar tudo por tudo encetando mais uma longa jornada rumo à erudição, uma jornada em que não estará só podendo contar com a valorosa companhia de Tali e de muitas criaturas mágicas que seguirão de perto os seus passos.
Após um primeiro livro em que tudo era novidade, é tempo de tecer e fortalecer laços, desta feita o leitor fica a conhecer profundamente os anseios do coração de todos os intervenientes da narrativa, sejam eles os Rebeldes, criaturas fantásticas ou até o suserano tirano Keldec, ao longo deste texto que se dedica, em partes iguais, ao desenvolvimento do enredo e às suas inúmeras personagens.
No que respeita aos Rebeldes, muitos são aqueles que contribuem para dar a conhecer o dia-a-dia na fortaleza de Shadowfell, deixando subentendidos os seus passados difíceis e, mais importante, permitindo que o leitor descubra os planos futuros de insurgência contra rei. De todos eles, para lá de Flint e Neryn, creio que é relevante destacar Regan, o líder, e Tali a guerreira.
Regan é típica voz do povo, sabendo exactamente como cativar, conquistar e a levar a que outros se juntem à sua luta. Justiça e honra são características inatas à sua pessoa, querida por todos e seguida como um exemplo entre os seus.
Tali, por sua vez, consegue ser o oposto, representando a necessidade de existir um lado menos emocional no texto. No entanto, a sua bravura, força e astucia são instrumentos poderosos e que fazem de si uma guerreira exemplar, mestra na sua arte, algo crucial e necessário nestes tempos difíceis. Devido à sua viagem com Neryn, ficamos a conhecê-la de uma forma íntima, acabando por ser uma personagem com elevado protagonismo que facilmente conquista quem lê.
No que respeita aos Boa Gente nem sei por onde começar. Eu já adorava Salva, Oco e Gorro Vermelho, que revemos durante a leitura, mas fiquei encantada com a diversidade de povos que nos são apresentados – como citei a jornada da protagonista é longa, da Vigia do Sul à Vigia do Norte, e a diferença entre os seres, todos eles peculiares, é uma mais-valia que comprova a criatividade surpreendente e inspiradora de Juliet.
A Bruxa das Ilhas, Vigia do Sul, é dos meus seres mágicos favoritos, pela sua ligação ao mar e pelo facto de ter um companheiro bem conhecido do folclore, um selkie, mas também no Norte me apaixonei por personagens como Flow ou os Dois, que representam bem a essência do fantástico.
Este não é um texto em que o romance abunde, ou seja, em que esteja presente de forma constante, mas a forma como está representado é enternecedora. A ligação entre Flint e Neryn é realmente muito especial, ainda mais atendendo à distancia física que os separa, pelo que se verifica o florescer dos sentimentos de ambos à par com os desenvolvimentos do enredo em que cada um intervém – o amadurecimento de Neryn e o que acontece no reino pela parte de Flint, que nos permite conhecer brevemente e vil esposa do rei. Este casal é, ainda, marcado pela moralidade e os valores que os acompanham e que são um ponto-chave do livro.
Tal como aconteceu anteriormente, e é algo que me parece ser recorrente nas obras desta autora, o leitor pode contar com a abordagem constante a valores pertinentes, entre os quais se destacam a confiança e a paciência necessários para atingir metas heróicas, assim como a bondade, a partilha e a generosidade, características inatas de algumas personagens da narrativa.
A heterogeneidade dos cenários, belíssimos, em sintonia com a natureza, tal como tudo resto, são também lugares comuns da autora, pelo que do mar às montanhas, passando por florestas ou característicos povoados, não desiludirão os fãs desta escritora - que atende aos vários elementos e lhes confere um misticismo muito próprio e em concordância com o ambiente em que se desenvolve a acção.
Em suma, este livro é tão bom ou melhor que o primeiro e prima por ter todos os ingredientes que satisfarão os adeptos deste género literário. Das lutas à magia, com um toque encantador de romance e intriga, cenários épicos e personagens singulares, fazem de O Voo do Corvo uma escolha assertiva para os fãs de fantasia.
Opinião completa: http://historiasdeelphaba.blogspot.pt...
Doravante as minhas palavras pecam por se dirigirem apenas aos leitores que leram o primeiro livro da trilogia da Shadowfell pois, tal como fica claro na sinopse, há o risco de spoilers.
Esta narrativa retoma o texto onde terminou o seu antecedente, com chegada de Neryn à fortaleza dos rebeldes que tanto se esforçou para alcançar, Shadowfell.
Depois da sua imensa caminhada, repleta de perigos mas também de conhecimento e amadurecimento - em que teve oportunidade de criar laços com os Boa Gente -, a protagonista deste enredo encontra-se agora entre aqueles que procuram banir o verdadeiro mal do Reino de Alban, muitas vezes sacrificando sentimentos em prol da vingança pelas suas perdas irreparáveis, lutando pela Causa que acreditam ser justa aos tempos cruéis em que tentam sobreviver.
É certo que passado doloroso jamais será esquecido e que o presente se adivinha mais arriscado que nunca, mas existe uma batalha para organizar da qual dependerá o futuro de todos e todos, por sua vez, dependem das conquistas da Voz. Este é, portanto, um livro em que Neryn terá que dar tudo por tudo encetando mais uma longa jornada rumo à erudição, uma jornada em que não estará só podendo contar com a valorosa companhia de Tali e de muitas criaturas mágicas que seguirão de perto os seus passos.
Após um primeiro livro em que tudo era novidade, é tempo de tecer e fortalecer laços, desta feita o leitor fica a conhecer profundamente os anseios do coração de todos os intervenientes da narrativa, sejam eles os Rebeldes, criaturas fantásticas ou até o suserano tirano Keldec, ao longo deste texto que se dedica, em partes iguais, ao desenvolvimento do enredo e às suas inúmeras personagens.
No que respeita aos Rebeldes, muitos são aqueles que contribuem para dar a conhecer o dia-a-dia na fortaleza de Shadowfell, deixando subentendidos os seus passados difíceis e, mais importante, permitindo que o leitor descubra os planos futuros de insurgência contra rei. De todos eles, para lá de Flint e Neryn, creio que é relevante destacar Regan, o líder, e Tali a guerreira.
Regan é típica voz do povo, sabendo exactamente como cativar, conquistar e a levar a que outros se juntem à sua luta. Justiça e honra são características inatas à sua pessoa, querida por todos e seguida como um exemplo entre os seus.
Tali, por sua vez, consegue ser o oposto, representando a necessidade de existir um lado menos emocional no texto. No entanto, a sua bravura, força e astucia são instrumentos poderosos e que fazem de si uma guerreira exemplar, mestra na sua arte, algo crucial e necessário nestes tempos difíceis. Devido à sua viagem com Neryn, ficamos a conhecê-la de uma forma íntima, acabando por ser uma personagem com elevado protagonismo que facilmente conquista quem lê.
No que respeita aos Boa Gente nem sei por onde começar. Eu já adorava Salva, Oco e Gorro Vermelho, que revemos durante a leitura, mas fiquei encantada com a diversidade de povos que nos são apresentados – como citei a jornada da protagonista é longa, da Vigia do Sul à Vigia do Norte, e a diferença entre os seres, todos eles peculiares, é uma mais-valia que comprova a criatividade surpreendente e inspiradora de Juliet.
A Bruxa das Ilhas, Vigia do Sul, é dos meus seres mágicos favoritos, pela sua ligação ao mar e pelo facto de ter um companheiro bem conhecido do folclore, um selkie, mas também no Norte me apaixonei por personagens como Flow ou os Dois, que representam bem a essência do fantástico.
Este não é um texto em que o romance abunde, ou seja, em que esteja presente de forma constante, mas a forma como está representado é enternecedora. A ligação entre Flint e Neryn é realmente muito especial, ainda mais atendendo à distancia física que os separa, pelo que se verifica o florescer dos sentimentos de ambos à par com os desenvolvimentos do enredo em que cada um intervém – o amadurecimento de Neryn e o que acontece no reino pela parte de Flint, que nos permite conhecer brevemente e vil esposa do rei. Este casal é, ainda, marcado pela moralidade e os valores que os acompanham e que são um ponto-chave do livro.
Tal como aconteceu anteriormente, e é algo que me parece ser recorrente nas obras desta autora, o leitor pode contar com a abordagem constante a valores pertinentes, entre os quais se destacam a confiança e a paciência necessários para atingir metas heróicas, assim como a bondade, a partilha e a generosidade, características inatas de algumas personagens da narrativa.
A heterogeneidade dos cenários, belíssimos, em sintonia com a natureza, tal como tudo resto, são também lugares comuns da autora, pelo que do mar às montanhas, passando por florestas ou característicos povoados, não desiludirão os fãs desta escritora - que atende aos vários elementos e lhes confere um misticismo muito próprio e em concordância com o ambiente em que se desenvolve a acção.
Em suma, este livro é tão bom ou melhor que o primeiro e prima por ter todos os ingredientes que satisfarão os adeptos deste género literário. Das lutas à magia, com um toque encantador de romance e intriga, cenários épicos e personagens singulares, fazem de O Voo do Corvo uma escolha assertiva para os fãs de fantasia.
Opinião completa: http://historiasdeelphaba.blogspot.pt...
December 18, 2020
Eu desconfiava que não ia aguentar muito tempo sem ler a continuação de Shadowffell e ainda bem que não esperei.
Neste segundo volume, Neryn parte na sua demanda para aperfeiçoar o seu Dom junto dos Guardi��es e acaba por ser um livro com um pouco menos de ritmo mas, ainda assim, temos acontecimentos que nos tiram o fôlego e nos deixam com o coração apertado.
Apesar de o romance não ser o ponto fulcral da história, sabemos que essa ligação está lá mas, em O Voo do Corvo, Neryn e Flint têm percursos mais separados, apesar de se cruzarem algumas vezes. No entanto, ficamos a descobrir um pouco sobre Flint e das suas funções enquanto Subjugador.
Uma grande surpresa foi Tali, uma das guerreiras dos rebeldes e que parte com Neryn para a proteger e, a par dos protagonistas, foi a minha personagem preferida.
Uma história com vários momentos que nos deixam ansiosos e que me faz querer pegar no último livro muito mas muito em breve!
Vídeo de opinião aqui
Neste segundo volume, Neryn parte na sua demanda para aperfeiçoar o seu Dom junto dos Guardi��es e acaba por ser um livro com um pouco menos de ritmo mas, ainda assim, temos acontecimentos que nos tiram o fôlego e nos deixam com o coração apertado.
Apesar de o romance não ser o ponto fulcral da história, sabemos que essa ligação está lá mas, em O Voo do Corvo, Neryn e Flint têm percursos mais separados, apesar de se cruzarem algumas vezes. No entanto, ficamos a descobrir um pouco sobre Flint e das suas funções enquanto Subjugador.
Uma grande surpresa foi Tali, uma das guerreiras dos rebeldes e que parte com Neryn para a proteger e, a par dos protagonistas, foi a minha personagem preferida.
Uma história com vários momentos que nos deixam ansiosos e que me faz querer pegar no último livro muito mas muito em breve!
Vídeo de opinião aqui
November 5, 2013
Opinião do blogue Chaise Longue: http://girlinchaiselongue.blogspot.pt...
Muito já foi dito sobre Juliet Marillier. Ela é a autora mais amada da Fantasia e os seus livros apaixonam todos aqueles que têm a honra, o prazer de os ler. Um séquito imenso de fãs segue-a desde a publicação de A Filha da Floresta, e todos os seus livros, sem excepção, provocam sentimentos nos seus leitores, sejam bons ou maus, mais intensos ou menos. Se as coisas têm andado mais agrestes com a publicação dos últimos três livros de Sevenwaters, a verdade é que uma nova série, uma nova história, tem voltado a agarrar os seus leitores senão da mesma forma, pelo menos de uma forma muito própria, demonstrando o seu mérito, o seu brilho.
Shadowfell virou a maré e encheu os corações com a sua história de Bem e Mal, de criaturas fantásticas, de heroínas predestinadas, de amores condenados que refulgem contra tudo e todos e, agora, a sua continuação chega para nos continuar a contar a história de uma das protagonistas mais fortes do Mundo Marilliano.
O Voo do Corvo foi publicado no primeiro dia deste ano e já está traduzido para a nossa língua e para holandês.
Apaixonei-me por Shadowfell logo na primeira página. Fui transportada para dentro da sua história com uma intensidade que só os livros de Marillier conseguem. Senti na pele todas as dores, as alegrias, as dúvidas das suas personagens e, um ano depois, todas estas sensações voltaram a dominar-me enquanto me perdia na leitura de O Voo do Corvo. Voltar a rever este mundo, fez-me apaixonar por ele outra vez, com mais intensidade, com mais dedicação e isso deve-se muito à voz única de Juliet. Já lhe chamei bardo dos tempos antigos em muitas outras opiniões e volto a fazê-lo, porque a sua escrita é mágica, a sua forma de contar uma história única e avassaladora, a sua voz é inigualável. Ler um livro seu é um doce tormento, é perdermo-nos nas palavras e sermos conquistados uma e outra vez com um sorriso nos lábios.
Como todas as histórias de Juliet, também esta é um eco das histórias de embalar contadas por tempos imemoráveis, destinadas a encantar e a ensinar, cheias de mensagens de coragem e bondade, de verdade e companheirismo, de amor e tormento, histórias que nos fazem sonhar enquanto a dura realidade nos coloca à prova. Ao longo deste livro vamos encontrar tudo isto e muito mais num enredo cheio de lições e obstáculos, perdas e pequenas alegrias, que nos vai agarrar na primeira palavra e deixar-nos a desejar ter o próximo livro já à mão na última. Como qualquer história de assim ser digna de ser chamada, esta tem uma demanda que irá colocar as forças do Bem contra as do Mal brevemente mas, para isso, é preciso aprender, é preciso crescer, é preciso encontrar a força e a coragem que só os heróis têm. Por vezes doce, por vezes cruel, esta é uma história maravilhosa, cheia de criaturas fantásticas, lendas vivas, duras aprendizagens e amores condenados, que se vai desenrolando frente aos nossos olhos de uma forma apaixonante e encantadora onde o mal não pode ser evitado mas torna as convicções ainda mais fortes, mais ardentes, mais desejosas de um final feliz.
Ao longo dos vários acontecimentos deste livro há duas forças que se degladiam momento a momento, através de actos e palavras. Estes dois sentimentos tão opostos estão presentes ao longo de toda a narrativa e cimentam toda a história. A esperança é uma luz por vezes forte, outras vezes quase apagada, que vive na coragem, na amizade, nas recordações, nos sonhos daqueles que lutam por uma vida melhor. Mas o desespero também está sempre lá, na impotência, na incompreensão, nas perdas por um bem maior. Há um equilíbrio sempre presente, um equilíbrio necessário não só na Natureza como nos actos humanos que tornam esta história tanto senhora de boas memórias como de lágrimas abundantes. Somos atormentados em vários momentos de perda e quase derrota, naquele final inesperado. Atormentados numa miríade de situações que nos colocam o coração na boca mas, também há momentos em que somos adoçados, em que tudo parece melhor nem que seja fugazmente, em que nos sentimos capazes de acreditar em tudo.
Com laivos de tempos antigos, de tradição e magia, O Voo do Corvo vai buscar os temas habituais de uma história marilliana mas dá-lhe uma alma própria, a alma dos heróis de Shadowfell, um grupo único de personagens pelos quais é impossível não sentirmos um grande carinho. Neryn cresceu neste livro, mais, mostra-se mais sábia, mais adulta, mais forte até, conseguindo cativar-nos, conseguindo mostrar que afinal pudera estar à altura do que se espera dela. Acompanhá-la na sua demanda faz com que apreciemos mais, principalmente quando percebemos que o seu modo desconfiado e fugidio já lá vai. Mas Flint continua a ser a personagem adorada nesta história mesmo que não apareça tanto. De cada vez que ele aparece apenas faz com que o leitor o adore mais e mais. Contudo, a grande surpresa deste livro foi Talli, a preciosa guerreira que se vai mostrando ao longo da história e que nos toca o coração em vários momentos, principalmente quando nos faz lembrar uma das minhas personagens mais queridas de Sevenwaters, Ciarán.
Depois de uma longa espera, este livro foi muito mais do que me atrevi a esperar, ultrapassando as minhas expectativas, deixando-me desejosa de saber o que se segue. Como sempre, Juliet encanta-nos em mais uma história que deixará os fãs da Fantasia rendidos. O Voo do Corvo é a continuação que Shadowfell merecia e muito mais do se poderia antecipar. Preparem-se pois não sabem o que vos espera. Ou talvez sim, afinal, é mais uma história da Senhora mais amada da Fantasia, a maior contadora de histórias do nosso tempo.
Muito já foi dito sobre Juliet Marillier. Ela é a autora mais amada da Fantasia e os seus livros apaixonam todos aqueles que têm a honra, o prazer de os ler. Um séquito imenso de fãs segue-a desde a publicação de A Filha da Floresta, e todos os seus livros, sem excepção, provocam sentimentos nos seus leitores, sejam bons ou maus, mais intensos ou menos. Se as coisas têm andado mais agrestes com a publicação dos últimos três livros de Sevenwaters, a verdade é que uma nova série, uma nova história, tem voltado a agarrar os seus leitores senão da mesma forma, pelo menos de uma forma muito própria, demonstrando o seu mérito, o seu brilho.
Shadowfell virou a maré e encheu os corações com a sua história de Bem e Mal, de criaturas fantásticas, de heroínas predestinadas, de amores condenados que refulgem contra tudo e todos e, agora, a sua continuação chega para nos continuar a contar a história de uma das protagonistas mais fortes do Mundo Marilliano.
O Voo do Corvo foi publicado no primeiro dia deste ano e já está traduzido para a nossa língua e para holandês.
Apaixonei-me por Shadowfell logo na primeira página. Fui transportada para dentro da sua história com uma intensidade que só os livros de Marillier conseguem. Senti na pele todas as dores, as alegrias, as dúvidas das suas personagens e, um ano depois, todas estas sensações voltaram a dominar-me enquanto me perdia na leitura de O Voo do Corvo. Voltar a rever este mundo, fez-me apaixonar por ele outra vez, com mais intensidade, com mais dedicação e isso deve-se muito à voz única de Juliet. Já lhe chamei bardo dos tempos antigos em muitas outras opiniões e volto a fazê-lo, porque a sua escrita é mágica, a sua forma de contar uma história única e avassaladora, a sua voz é inigualável. Ler um livro seu é um doce tormento, é perdermo-nos nas palavras e sermos conquistados uma e outra vez com um sorriso nos lábios.
Como todas as histórias de Juliet, também esta é um eco das histórias de embalar contadas por tempos imemoráveis, destinadas a encantar e a ensinar, cheias de mensagens de coragem e bondade, de verdade e companheirismo, de amor e tormento, histórias que nos fazem sonhar enquanto a dura realidade nos coloca à prova. Ao longo deste livro vamos encontrar tudo isto e muito mais num enredo cheio de lições e obstáculos, perdas e pequenas alegrias, que nos vai agarrar na primeira palavra e deixar-nos a desejar ter o próximo livro já à mão na última. Como qualquer história de assim ser digna de ser chamada, esta tem uma demanda que irá colocar as forças do Bem contra as do Mal brevemente mas, para isso, é preciso aprender, é preciso crescer, é preciso encontrar a força e a coragem que só os heróis têm. Por vezes doce, por vezes cruel, esta é uma história maravilhosa, cheia de criaturas fantásticas, lendas vivas, duras aprendizagens e amores condenados, que se vai desenrolando frente aos nossos olhos de uma forma apaixonante e encantadora onde o mal não pode ser evitado mas torna as convicções ainda mais fortes, mais ardentes, mais desejosas de um final feliz.
Ao longo dos vários acontecimentos deste livro há duas forças que se degladiam momento a momento, através de actos e palavras. Estes dois sentimentos tão opostos estão presentes ao longo de toda a narrativa e cimentam toda a história. A esperança é uma luz por vezes forte, outras vezes quase apagada, que vive na coragem, na amizade, nas recordações, nos sonhos daqueles que lutam por uma vida melhor. Mas o desespero também está sempre lá, na impotência, na incompreensão, nas perdas por um bem maior. Há um equilíbrio sempre presente, um equilíbrio necessário não só na Natureza como nos actos humanos que tornam esta história tanto senhora de boas memórias como de lágrimas abundantes. Somos atormentados em vários momentos de perda e quase derrota, naquele final inesperado. Atormentados numa miríade de situações que nos colocam o coração na boca mas, também há momentos em que somos adoçados, em que tudo parece melhor nem que seja fugazmente, em que nos sentimos capazes de acreditar em tudo.
Com laivos de tempos antigos, de tradição e magia, O Voo do Corvo vai buscar os temas habituais de uma história marilliana mas dá-lhe uma alma própria, a alma dos heróis de Shadowfell, um grupo único de personagens pelos quais é impossível não sentirmos um grande carinho. Neryn cresceu neste livro, mais, mostra-se mais sábia, mais adulta, mais forte até, conseguindo cativar-nos, conseguindo mostrar que afinal pudera estar à altura do que se espera dela. Acompanhá-la na sua demanda faz com que apreciemos mais, principalmente quando percebemos que o seu modo desconfiado e fugidio já lá vai. Mas Flint continua a ser a personagem adorada nesta história mesmo que não apareça tanto. De cada vez que ele aparece apenas faz com que o leitor o adore mais e mais. Contudo, a grande surpresa deste livro foi Talli, a preciosa guerreira que se vai mostrando ao longo da história e que nos toca o coração em vários momentos, principalmente quando nos faz lembrar uma das minhas personagens mais queridas de Sevenwaters, Ciarán.
Depois de uma longa espera, este livro foi muito mais do que me atrevi a esperar, ultrapassando as minhas expectativas, deixando-me desejosa de saber o que se segue. Como sempre, Juliet encanta-nos em mais uma história que deixará os fãs da Fantasia rendidos. O Voo do Corvo é a continuação que Shadowfell merecia e muito mais do se poderia antecipar. Preparem-se pois não sabem o que vos espera. Ou talvez sim, afinal, é mais uma história da Senhora mais amada da Fantasia, a maior contadora de histórias do nosso tempo.
January 28, 2016
Raven Flight is the second in Juliet Marillier's Shadowfell trilogy. In book one, Neryn discovered she was a Caller, one who possesses the gifts to call the Good Folk forward to fight on the side of the humans. It was a rough go for Neryn. She didn't know who to trust or even if she wanted to be the Caller.
In Raven Flight Neryn has come to terms with her role as the Caller and it's now time for her to hone her gifts. She's used her ability in the past, but her lack of training makes her a danger to those around her. To learn more about her abilities Neryn will need to go on a journey and learn from the four Guardians. The journey is long and time is running short. Raven Flight is your typical middle trilogy book. Quite frankly there's not a lot going on here. Once again there is a lot of traveling as Neryn goes to search for the Guardians that can teach her how to harness her abilities. A lot of time is spent on Neryn learning about her capabilities as well as her role in the larger conflict. Neryn has to come to terms with the fact that she is going to hurt and ultimately kill people with her gift, and this is a struggle for her, but a necessary lesson.
What I liked about Raven Flight is that readers get to learn more about other characters in the rebellion. In particular, Neryn is escorted on her journey by the belligerent Tali. Tali is not happy about accompanying Neryn. She is the right-hand to the leader of the rebellion and she does not want to leave him unprotected. But orders are orders, so Tali protects Neryn throughout their journey. I liked seeing more of Tali as I think she represents another element of the rebellion. She is completely focused on the ultimate goal of getting rid of the tyrant, King Keldec. Tali doesn't believe in making connections with others and she is not shy about sharing her disapproval of Neryn's relationship with Flint. In Tali's mind, there's no point in having relationships with other people; many are likely to die. However, Tali learns a hard lesson about this when someone close to her dies without knowing how she feels about them. What's the point of fighting for a future if you have no hope for it? I really liked Tali as a character. She's strong, as are her opinions, but I find her a really interesting character and I hope that she continues to have a major presence in book three.
What I was less enthused about in Raven Flight was the romance. Ugh. Not a fan of it at all. In Shadowfell Neryn found herself reluctantly forming a friendship with Flint, a double agent for the rebellion. There was a lot of back and forth between them, but suddenly in Raven Flight they're all in love and what not. Quite simply, I just don't buy it. These two barely spend any time together and now they have all these deep emotions. Personally, I thought that they came out of no where considering there is very little interaction between them in Raven Flight. The romance came off as insta-love, which is not my favourite element in young adult novels. A little more development with this plot would have went a long way in making this relationship a stronger one.
I also struggled with the pacing in Raven Flight. I had a hard time getting through this one. There was just so much traveling and pauses for Neryn to learn. The pacing was so start-and-stop it was hard to motivate myself to read through to the end. Paradoxically, it was the end that changed my opinion on Raven Flight. The novel ends full of action and heartbreak, I was left desperately wanting to read the final installment. I am hoping that the pacing of the final book will be a little more even since the slow build up to conflict is clearly not my preferred style of plot.
Ultimately, Raven Flight did an adequate job of continuing the story of Shadowfell. The issues I had with book one, continued into the second book, but much of that has to do with personal reading taste. As much as I'm not found of the meandering pacing, I do want to know how the conflict with the king will be resolved and whether or not Flint and Neryn get their happily ever after.
Originally published at The Book Adventures.
In Raven Flight Neryn has come to terms with her role as the Caller and it's now time for her to hone her gifts. She's used her ability in the past, but her lack of training makes her a danger to those around her. To learn more about her abilities Neryn will need to go on a journey and learn from the four Guardians. The journey is long and time is running short. Raven Flight is your typical middle trilogy book. Quite frankly there's not a lot going on here. Once again there is a lot of traveling as Neryn goes to search for the Guardians that can teach her how to harness her abilities. A lot of time is spent on Neryn learning about her capabilities as well as her role in the larger conflict. Neryn has to come to terms with the fact that she is going to hurt and ultimately kill people with her gift, and this is a struggle for her, but a necessary lesson.
What I liked about Raven Flight is that readers get to learn more about other characters in the rebellion. In particular, Neryn is escorted on her journey by the belligerent Tali. Tali is not happy about accompanying Neryn. She is the right-hand to the leader of the rebellion and she does not want to leave him unprotected. But orders are orders, so Tali protects Neryn throughout their journey. I liked seeing more of Tali as I think she represents another element of the rebellion. She is completely focused on the ultimate goal of getting rid of the tyrant, King Keldec. Tali doesn't believe in making connections with others and she is not shy about sharing her disapproval of Neryn's relationship with Flint. In Tali's mind, there's no point in having relationships with other people; many are likely to die. However, Tali learns a hard lesson about this when someone close to her dies without knowing how she feels about them. What's the point of fighting for a future if you have no hope for it? I really liked Tali as a character. She's strong, as are her opinions, but I find her a really interesting character and I hope that she continues to have a major presence in book three.
What I was less enthused about in Raven Flight was the romance. Ugh. Not a fan of it at all. In Shadowfell Neryn found herself reluctantly forming a friendship with Flint, a double agent for the rebellion. There was a lot of back and forth between them, but suddenly in Raven Flight they're all in love and what not. Quite simply, I just don't buy it. These two barely spend any time together and now they have all these deep emotions. Personally, I thought that they came out of no where considering there is very little interaction between them in Raven Flight. The romance came off as insta-love, which is not my favourite element in young adult novels. A little more development with this plot would have went a long way in making this relationship a stronger one.
I also struggled with the pacing in Raven Flight. I had a hard time getting through this one. There was just so much traveling and pauses for Neryn to learn. The pacing was so start-and-stop it was hard to motivate myself to read through to the end. Paradoxically, it was the end that changed my opinion on Raven Flight. The novel ends full of action and heartbreak, I was left desperately wanting to read the final installment. I am hoping that the pacing of the final book will be a little more even since the slow build up to conflict is clearly not my preferred style of plot.
Ultimately, Raven Flight did an adequate job of continuing the story of Shadowfell. The issues I had with book one, continued into the second book, but much of that has to do with personal reading taste. As much as I'm not found of the meandering pacing, I do want to know how the conflict with the king will be resolved and whether or not Flint and Neryn get their happily ever after.
Originally published at The Book Adventures.
February 4, 2014
A história de Neryn e Flint começou em Shadowfell e a promessa de que muito ainda estava para acontecer cumpriu-se. O Voo do Corvo, continuação dessa narrativa, é uma obra que não apazigua, pelo contrário, revolve-nos por dentro semeando a ansiedade e a necessidade de avançar sempre cada vez mais na história. Acima de tudo acaba por ser um ponto de paragem obrigatório entre o início e o fim da trama, servindo mais como uma ponte entre o que aconteceu e o que está para vir.
Neryn, depois da sua recuperação, começa finalmente algum treino físico antes de partir à procura do conhecimento que os Guardiães lhe podem fornecer para se tornar na Voz que todos esperam. É Tali quem fica encarregue de a acompanhar e assim partem as duas, rumo a um destino incerto, mas cujos resultados esperados funcionam como força motriz.
Para quem iniciou a sua aventura na escrita de Juliet Marillier com o mundo de Sevenwaters, será sempre complicado evitar fazer comparações no que toca às histórias de amor e até à contribuição das personagens femininas. Neryn não é uma personagem tão forte e empática como Liadan ou até Sorcha, nem Flint um Red ou um Bran. Talvez por ser virado para o público jovem-adulto a autora tenha optado por fazer algo mais leve, mas que ainda assim enternece os mais românticos.
Gosto da forma como Juliet Marillier continua a aplicar a sua costela druida nas suas obras. Sendo eu uma curiosa pela doutrina druida, agrada-me a conjugação da aprendizagem da Voz com os elementos, a dinâmica do respeito e da manipulação dos mesmos sempre consciente da importância e da ligação à natureza. Cada elemento tem as suas características e a forma como cada um é abordado está original e solene.
A narrativa alterna entre boa dose de acção e emoção com alguns momentos mais parados. Ficamos muito tempo sem notícias dos Rebeldes e quando chegam nem sempre é para nos deixar de sorriso no rosto. Não esperem paninhos quentes nem finais totalmente felizes. Adorei o papel de Tali e admiro-a imenso. Também gostava de ver esta história narrada através de Flint, penso que daria uma perspectiva muito interessante e com mais informações sobre o reino de Keldec. As poucas visões que nos são dadas sabem a pouco.
Resumindo, quando se começa fica difícil largar e o fim deixa-nos a sofrer pelo próximo capítulo para que possamos fechar a história da rebelião. Tem amor, violência, crueldade, sentido de lealdade e uma capacidade de sacrifício estonteantes. A escrita é fluida e intensa e os personagens de personalidades fortes e únicas. Uma bela continuação que nos deixa a querer mais.
Neryn, depois da sua recuperação, começa finalmente algum treino físico antes de partir à procura do conhecimento que os Guardiães lhe podem fornecer para se tornar na Voz que todos esperam. É Tali quem fica encarregue de a acompanhar e assim partem as duas, rumo a um destino incerto, mas cujos resultados esperados funcionam como força motriz.
Para quem iniciou a sua aventura na escrita de Juliet Marillier com o mundo de Sevenwaters, será sempre complicado evitar fazer comparações no que toca às histórias de amor e até à contribuição das personagens femininas. Neryn não é uma personagem tão forte e empática como Liadan ou até Sorcha, nem Flint um Red ou um Bran. Talvez por ser virado para o público jovem-adulto a autora tenha optado por fazer algo mais leve, mas que ainda assim enternece os mais românticos.
Gosto da forma como Juliet Marillier continua a aplicar a sua costela druida nas suas obras. Sendo eu uma curiosa pela doutrina druida, agrada-me a conjugação da aprendizagem da Voz com os elementos, a dinâmica do respeito e da manipulação dos mesmos sempre consciente da importância e da ligação à natureza. Cada elemento tem as suas características e a forma como cada um é abordado está original e solene.
A narrativa alterna entre boa dose de acção e emoção com alguns momentos mais parados. Ficamos muito tempo sem notícias dos Rebeldes e quando chegam nem sempre é para nos deixar de sorriso no rosto. Não esperem paninhos quentes nem finais totalmente felizes. Adorei o papel de Tali e admiro-a imenso. Também gostava de ver esta história narrada através de Flint, penso que daria uma perspectiva muito interessante e com mais informações sobre o reino de Keldec. As poucas visões que nos são dadas sabem a pouco.
Resumindo, quando se começa fica difícil largar e o fim deixa-nos a sofrer pelo próximo capítulo para que possamos fechar a história da rebelião. Tem amor, violência, crueldade, sentido de lealdade e uma capacidade de sacrifício estonteantes. A escrita é fluida e intensa e os personagens de personalidades fortes e únicas. Uma bela continuação que nos deixa a querer mais.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 640 reviews