Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abdul Samad Dawood (2nd nomination)
[Hide this box] New to Articles for deletion (AfD)? Read these primers!
- Abdul Samad Dawood (edit | talk | history | protect | delete | links | watch | logs | views) – (View log | edits since nomination)
- (Find sources: Google (books · news · scholar · free images · WP refs) · FENS · JSTOR · TWL)
Little has changed in his fortunes since the last AFD eight months ago. He's still a successful and civic-minded businessman from a prominent Pakistani business family, and has worked at a high level for some notable companies. But on Wikipedia, notability is not inherited. I couldn't find SIGCOV of him in English or Urdu, just passing mentions in articles about the companies and organisations he's worked for, nothing to bring it up to the standard of WP:BIO or WP:GNG. Wikishovel (talk) 17:16, 23 August 2024 (UTC)
- Note: This discussion has been included in the deletion sorting lists for the following topics: Businesspeople and Pakistan. Wikishovel (talk) 17:16, 23 August 2024 (UTC)
If you came here because someone asked you to, or you read a message on another website, please note that this is not a majority vote, but instead a discussion among Wikipedia contributors. Wikipedia has policies and guidelines regarding the encyclopedia's content, and consensus (agreement) is gauged based on the merits of the arguments, not by counting votes.
However, you are invited to participate and your opinion is welcome. Remember to assume good faith on the part of others and to sign your posts on this page by adding ~~~~ at the end. Note: Comments may be tagged as follows: suspected single-purpose accounts:{{subst:spa|username}} ; suspected canvassed users: {{subst:canvassed|username}} ; accounts blocked for sockpuppetry: {{subst:csm|username}} or {{subst:csp|username}} . |
- Comment: If only he had appeared in a few dramas, even in tiny roles, his BLP might have been easily saved from deletion under WP:NACTOR! But it’s ironic that someone so important in Pakistan's business community doesn’t have enough coverage that meets GNG. Anyway, I’ll hold off on voting for now. PS. No offense to the nominator Wikishovel, who also has legitimate reasons for taking it to AFD. — Saqib (talk I contribs) 17:37, 23 August 2024 (UTC)
- Delete: Still not a slam dunk; outside of the Engro connection, there are no RS that discuss him and we only have source 13 that is helpful. Rest are yellow per Source Highlighter, so of moderate reliability. I still don't see/find much else we can use. Oaktree b (talk) 22:37, 23 August 2024 (UTC)
- Keep: The article follows the guidelines of WP:GNG and WP:SIGCOV as it demonstrates significant coverage in both Pakistani and international media, meeting WP:RS. As per WP:BASIC, “People are presumed notable if they have received significant coverage in multiple published[4] secondary sources that are reliable, intellectually independent of each other,[5] and independent of the subject.[6]” Please feel free to check the sources, they meet all the mentioned criteria. Crosji (talk) 07:11, 24 August 2024 (UTC)
- Keep Reuters is RS.--Ameen Akbar (talk) 14:03, 24 August 2024 (UTC)
- The Reuters reference is indeed a reliable source, but that article is a summarised interview, and interviews are WP:Primary sources. Wikishovel (talk) 07:10, 6 September 2024 (UTC)
- Delete non-notable obscure business executive. Already deleted under Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Samad Dawood. I suggest to WP:SALT the topic because Dawood family won't stop paying these UPEs. 188.31.32.162 (talk) 20:35, 24 August 2024 (UTC)
- Comment: This statement clearly violates WP:AFDEQ by making personal remarks about the subject. Given this user's anonymity, it could potentially be part of a coordinated attack, possibly even Wikipedia:Sockpuppetry.
- Crosji (talk) 08:13, 29 August 2024 (UTC)
- Delete. Non-notable at this time. The sources that are not not primary/self-published, Reuters, Financial Post, The News, can be considered trivial mentions at most, but not significant coverage about Dawood. These sources are a better proof of notability for the corporation, Engro, not for Dawood himself. Prof.PMarini (talk) 08:31, 27 August 2024 (UTC)
- Keep this is WP:V and there exist WP:NEXIST 202.141.250.250 (talk) 11:47, 29 August 2024 (UTC)— 202.141.250.250 (talk) has made few or no other edits outside this topic.
Relisted to generate a more thorough discussion and clearer consensus.
Please add new comments below this notice. Thanks, Doczilla Ohhhhhh, no! 19:44, 30 August 2024 (UTC)
- Redirect to Dawood Hercules Corporation because he's prominent businessman serving on the board of various companies under Dawood Hercules Corporation. — Saqib (talk I contribs) 14:41, 5 September 2024 (UTC)
KeepThe references for this article are strong, even for a stub. The subject is a notable businessman in Pakistan with occasional public appearances. His notability is supported by coverage from reputable national newspapers and some international outlets. The first deletion discussion, with only one vote for deletion, appeared premature. Hence the new article has been improved with additional sources. While contributions are welcome, the arguments for deletion are not in line with policy. -Crosji (talk) 06:48, 6 September 2024 (UTC)
- Strikethrough of second !vote: in an WP:AFD discussion, we get to post our recommendation just once. You're welcome to comment as much as you like. Wikishovel (talk) 07:03, 6 September 2024 (UTC)
Keep: While there may not be extensive media coverage, the subject is undoubtedly an influential figure in Pakistan’s business community, as highlighted by Saqib and others above. The significance is evident through the inclusion in government advisory groups and recognized contributions. The cited sources, including interviews with reputable, independent global media, further reinforce the prominence. Instead of debating the subject’s notability, efforts would be better spent refining and improving the article.
- 202.141.250.250 (talk) 10:56, 6 September 2024 (UTC)
- Strikethrough of second !vote: in an WP:AFD discussion, we get to post our recommendation just once. You're welcome to comment as much as you like. Wikishovel (talk) 11:08, 6 September 2024 (UTC)
- Strikethrough of second !vote: in an WP:AFD discussion, we get to post our recommendation just once. You're welcome to comment as much as you like. Wikishovel (talk) 07:03, 6 September 2024 (UTC)
- Keep: The sources are solid. The fact that there is coverage from independent national newspapers support notability.
- 119.155.63.175 (talk) 16:03, 6 September 2024 (UTC)— 119.155.63.175 (talk) has made few or no other edits outside this topic.
Note: Closing admin should disregard some IP votes, as it appears that canvassing may be influencing the outcome. --— Saqib (talk I contribs) 16:13, 6 September 2024 (UTC)
Relisted to generate a more thorough discussion and clearer consensus.
Relisting comment: Relisting as I still don't see a consensus (even after disregarding second "votes" that were cast). A source review could be helpful as well as arguments based in policy. Opinions, both pro and con, based on who he is related to, are not useful to an AFD discussion.
Please add new comments below this notice. Thanks, Liz Read! Talk! 22:33, 6 September 2024 (UTC)
Redirect to Dawood Hercules Corporation. I was in the process of closing as such, but as we edit conflicted will just leave this as a !vote. He does not merit a standalone, but the target makes sense. Protect if needed against disruptive recreation. Star Mississippi 22:35, 6 September 2024 (UTC)
- Comment here's a source assessment, as suggested by Liz above in the relisting comment:
Source assessment table: prepared by User:Wikishovel
| ||||
Source | Independent? | Reliable? | Significant coverage? | Count source toward GNG? |
---|---|---|---|---|
Karachi School of Business & Leadership, "Mr. Abdul Samad Dawood"[1] | profile page from a university of which he's on the board of governors | ✘ No | ||
Engro Corporation "Engro Corporation 1H 2021 Results" [2] | A press release by his employer announcing compamy results, mentions him briefly in one paragraph | ✘ No | ||
The Express Tribune "Summit highlights importance of girls’ education" [3] | Routine coverage of the International Women Leaders Summit, where he's mentioned in passing as an attendee | ✘ No | ||
The Express Tribune "Corporate Corner" | a photo of six CEOs and CFOs at a conference, with Dawood and the other five mentioned in passing in the caption | ✘ No | ||
Financial Post "Pakistan's Engro Looks To Invest In Other Developing Nations" | an article about Engro, with several quotes from an interview with Dawood | ✘ No | ||
Pakistan Stock Exchange "Resignation of Director" [4] | Formal letter to the stock exchange announcing Dawood's resignation from Cyan in 2014 | ✘ No | ||
Pakistan Stock Exchange "Board Meeting - Election of Chairman and appointment of CEO, CFO and Company Secretary"[5] | Another formal letter to the stock exchange announcing Dawood's election as chairman of Cyan in 2022 | ✘ No | ||
Pakistan Stock Exchange "Change of CEO" [6] | Another formal letter to the stock exchange announcing Dawood's appointment as CEO of Dawood Hercules in 2014 | ✘ No | ||
Pakistan Stock Exchange "Appointment of CEO" [7] | Another formal letter to the stock exchange announcing Dawood's resignation as CEO of Dawood Hercules in 2016 | ✘ No | ||
Business School Lausanne "PEBBLES (PVT) Ltd.: “Building Hopes” " [8] | Case study by a business school on a subsidiary company of Dawood Hercules, where Samad Dawood is mentioned in three places as the parent company's CEO, e.g. " the organization’s sustainability perspective and the journey it took to transform the dream of Mr. Samad Dawood, the CEO of Dawood Hercules Corporation, into a reality" | ✘ No | ||
The Express Tribune "Dutch company acquires Engro Foods for $446.81m"[9] | Article about another company taking over Engro Foods, with a quote from Dawood from the Engro press release. | ✘ No | ||
Reuters "Pakistani conglomerate Engro looks to go global, its main investor says" [10] | Interview with Dawood about Engro, primary source | ✘ No | ||
Pakistan Today " "Engro's Rs60 billion question" [11] | Article about the company, with several quotes from Dawood and some analysis of his role, meets SIGCOV. | ✔ Yes | ||
Khaadi "Abdul Samad Dawood"[12] | A short director profile by his employer, primary source. | ✘ No | ||
Pakistan Business Council "About PBC"[13] | Simply lists him as a board member. | ✘ No | ||
Hub Power Company "Annual Report 2016"[14] | Annual report simply lists him as a board member, with a short bio. | ✘ No | ||
Sui Northern Gas Pipelines Limited "Annual Report 2008"[15] | Annual report simply lists him as director, with a short bio. | ✘ No | ||
The News International "In rare visit, top Pakistani business leaders meet US officials"[16] | Routine coverage of a trade delegation to the US, mentions him in passing as one of the eight members. | ✘ No | ||
The Nation (Pakistan) "Inaugural meeting of Industrial Advisory Council held"[17] | Routine coverage of a government-backed business conference, mentions him in passing as one of the members attending. | ✘ No | ||
Pakistan Today "Govt establishes Industry Advisory Council to develop industrial policy"[18] | More routine coverage of the government-backed business conference above, mentions him in passing as one of the members attending. | ✘ No | ||
WWF–Pakistan "Annual report 2012"[19] | Listed on p. 56 in the list of board members | ✘ No | ||
Business Recorder "WWF-P holds awards ceremony"[20] | Routine coverage of awards ceremony, briefly mentions Dawood and another member getting certificates of appreciation | ✘ No | ||
ABC News (United States) "Titanic submersible victim’s deaths ‘brought the world together,’ Dawood family member says"[21] | Short interview with Samad Dawood on his grief following his brother's death in an accident, primary source. (Please see article for full URL: source assessment template doesn't work with full YouTube links with separators.) | ✘ No | ||
This table may not be a final or consensus view; it may summarize developing consensus, or reflect assessments of a single editor. Created using {{source assess table}}. |
Wikishovel (talk) 16:14, 7 September 2024 (UTC)
- Comment: I have just added an additional source from Bloomberg.com, a reputable and independent news outlet, further strengthening the subject’s notability. The table is impressive, though I am unclear why some quotes are not considered significant coverage, as they seem to meet GNG criteria:
- - The Reuters article is based on a direct interview with the subject.
- - The 2016 Express Tribune article by Salman Siddiqui, from one of Pakistan’s leading English-language newspapers, features prominent quotes from the subject.
- - Additionally, a university case study is inherently independent, so I wonder why this is being questioned. Crosji (talk) 11:21, 9 September 2024 (UTC)
Delete Not every single businessman from Pakistan becomes notable just for being involve in a business inside Pakistan. BLP lacks significant coverage in reliable sources and by looking at image it seems it is a case of COI. 39.34.141.22 (talk) 09:37, 10 September 2024 (UTC)
- Comment: Not sure why you haven't logged in yet, especially since you seem to have a deeper understanding than the average user. Check THIS VIDEO out to see that the involvement extends beyond Pakistan. - Crosji (talk) 10:30, 10 September 2024 (UTC)
- Delete per nom. Agree with Wikishovel's table above - I think Profit's article is about Engro so I would not count it as significant coverage about Dawood (I only found a few quotes from him in that article). 202.47.50.250 (talk) 04:28, 15 September 2024 (UTC)
- Comment: I am truly impressed by the expertise and subtlety of this contribution. It appears, however, that this necessitates you remaining anonymous and refraining from responding to my comments, which is quite unfortunate. Crosji (talk) 17:28, 15 September 2024 (UTC)