mark monday's Reviews > Anthem

Anthem by Ayn Rand
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
131922
's review

it was ok
bookshelves: after-the-fall, super-private-journal, unicorn

a long day at work with a lot of that work left unfinished
+ happy hour drinks with colleagues, no they're more than that, with friends
+ I have to get around to reviewing a book by mutterfookin' AYN RAND of all things
=

DRUNK ЯEVIEW #?

so I've been on a hiring spree lately, just hiring people left and right because yay my work is actually getting multiple contracts and that means we can actually hire people instead of everyone doing two jobs per usual nonprofit social services type staffing patterns, so anyway I hired this one young lady who is clearly super smart and super organized and super perfect for the job I hired her for, good job mark, yet again, but she is 21 and so I wonder sometimes if her big brain is the tail wagging the 21 year old, who is very, very much 21 years of age, or at least what I remember of myself when I was 21. namely, emotional. and critical. and all about RIGHT HERE RIGHT NOW. still, I'm pleased with the hire, she's great, I love her. and what does everything I just wrote even mean? in the context of this book? i dunno but it sorta made sense to me as I wrote it.

anyway, she somehow found out that I am a quote unquote Reader, and so she loaned me one of her favorite books. namely, this book. Anthem. my reaction was decidedly undecided when she mentioned this was one of her favorites. I hate everything I know about Ayn Rand. I am the sort of ass who, way back when i was 21 and in college, actually broke up with a lady I was dating because it was clear that all of the Ayn Rand she was reading was influencing her, she was quoting Ayn Rand for crissakes, anyway it was too much because Ayn Rand's ME ME ME style of libertarian philosofuckery just drives me up the wall and I can't have that in someone I'm dating. so she turned around and started dating my roommate, so someone got that last laugh there and it wasn't mark monday.

so my new staffer loaned me this book and i was all UH UH BUT AYN RAND SUCKS ARE YOU SERIOUS?? and she was all OH MY GOD JUST FUCKING TRY IT. so i did!

if you are one of the unwashed masses who doesn't know what Ayn Rand is all about, and God bless you if you are, here are some things about her (that I despise):

- totally against all forms of socialism because to Rand, socialism = the death of the individual

- the most important thing about this curious concept called "Self" is "Ego". Rand worships at the altar of EGO. per Rand, if you aren't your own #1, you may as well be dead. there are aspects of that mentality that I totally get and support, but Rand carries this to the point where concepts like "altruism" are inherently corrupt to her. an altruistic person per Rand is pretty much the definition of a total loser

- you are the captain of your own ship; if your ship carries important supplies that could help other people, who gives a fuck, fuck them; your ship needs to sail alone unless people are happy to sail under your personal captaincy. e.g. if you are a brilliant architect who designs a brilliant housing complex and then finds out that that your design is being used for public housing, God forbid, then you are fully entitled to blow up said brilliant housing complex because it is being used for the public good rather than for what you intended. YOUR PERSONAL DREAMS ÜBER ALLES!

which reminds me: one of my favorite films is King Vidor's insane adaptation of Rand's novel The Fountainhead, where what I just mentioned is the central struggle of the film (and I assume the novel). this over the top thing of beauty features a berserk plotline, berserk characters, a brilliant housing complex being blown up because God fucking forbid it may be used for public housing, and an incredible scene where architect Gary Cooper is drilling something and neurotic Patricia Neal is watching him drill and gets so worked up she uncontrollably starts beating the literal horse she rode in on, and then rides off, in a Randian heat over the studly I Am My Own Man-ishness of the Gary Cooper character. she gets so hot & bothered she actually delivers a smart slash of her riding crop before riding off. hot stuff!

 photo fca5887e1ce2e180d4618ebbe253f6c8_zpsjrifbhhl.jpg

 photo 101.jpg

 photo tumblr_nbmz91zTBB1s39hlao1_500_zpspxif6vjn.gif

but back to this book, finally

actual review:

I was surprised at how much I liked it, at first. it is one of those dystopic post-apocalyptic books where we are experiencing the day-to-day life of some poor zombie sap who is slowly realizing that he is living in a world of sad automatons and he is one of the few who gets how pathetic his life is. because everyone is supposed to be like everyone else, and he is an actual someone. as always, this is an automatically enjoyable narrative to live in because who doesn't think that way, at certain points in their lives (or at certain points in their day, cough)

the style and the prose itself impressed me. Rand is one of those surprising writers whose prose is stripped-down, clean, and neat while also being oddly poetic: phrases and sentences that are child-like, eager, but also full of longing and melancholy. she's a fully-formed writer as of Anthem, surprisingly only her second novel. even more impressive was her replacement of the word "I" with the word "We" which functioned as an implicit criticism of the communist mindset while giving the storytelling itself an excitingly declamatory feel. on a stylistic level, Anthem is a genuine pleasure to read.

oh I just got a text from a friend that was a link saying "typhoon pork bun woman" and I think I'm just not going to check that out right now. whatever could that mean??

anyway, this was turning out to be a from-leftfield 4 star book for me but then the last two chapters happened. there were hints before that, here and there, but I chose to ignore them. but Ayn Rand is gonna do Ayn Rand, and that's only bad news where women are concerned. per Rand, a person with a dick is a person who needs to make himself into his own man; a person without a dick should probably just follow and promise obedience to said dick.

THAT IS FUCKING DISAPPOINTING. but I suppose not surprising. and yet I am surprised! I'm always surprised when a woman is all about freedom and rugged individuality and notgivingaflyingfuckeroo about what society says... but for men only! not for the womenfolk! apparently women should just support their man, they are incapable of forging their own hard-won individuality because EMOTIONS. I wish this was a unique perspective but God knows I have come across it many times, in literature and ugh in real life too. my own experience of my own uh experiences but also of my male friends is that I, and they, are all super fucking emotional. this is not just a female trait! argh. but more to the point: the sole female in Anthem shows her worth by declaring her obedience to her ruggedly individualistic, freedom-living man. that's just fucking gross and I don't get it. self-hate much?

so anyway, looks like Survivor is on so time for me to end this review. also feels like I am going to have an interesting time reporting my findings to the person who loaned me this book. wish me luck!
309 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Anthem.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

September 23, 2016 – Started Reading
September 23, 2016 – Shelved
September 24, 2016 – Shelved as: after-the-fall
September 24, 2016 – Finished Reading
September 28, 2016 – Shelved as: super-private-journal
December 13, 2016 – Shelved as: unicorn

Comments Showing 1-50 of 98 (98 new)


Zombieslayer⚡Alienhunter I shamelessly admit the word philosofuckery in my peripheral vision drew me to this review, which wound up being awesome XD


mark monday :)


Erin *Proud Book Hoarder* Enjoyed your semi drunken review ;)


mark monday oh that wasn't semi-drunk, that was drunk-drunk! drinks right after work and then forgetting dinner altogether apparently means I'm a lightweight who gets wasted after only two and half drinks. almost immediately after writing this review, I stumbled into bed at an unreasonably early hour. which is why I'm now awake 7 hours later at 4:25 am, painfully sober, watching Survivor and eating my dinner. or rather, breakfast.


message 5: by Lynne (new)

Lynne King I also enjoyed your review Mark and especially the images!


message 6: by Jeff (new)

Jeff If anybody deserves a drunken review it's Ayn Rand (or John Dos Passos). Well done, mark!


mark monday thanks Jeff!

Lynne, that movie is fantastic, if you like over-the-top melodramas directed with flair, I highly recommend it. as well as King Vidor's similarly hyperventilating western, Duel in the Sun.


Erin *Proud Book Hoarder* mark wrote: "oh that wasn't semi-drunk, that was drunk-drunk! drinks right after work and then forgetting dinner altogether apparently means I'm a lightweight who gets wasted after only two and half drinks. alm..."

I'm impressed you can write a drunken review then. I can barely type if I'm over my limit, let alone string together coherent sentences.


mark monday I've been told that I came across as alert and articulate when drunk, and yet sometimes appear drunk in social settings where I haven't had a single drink. curious! I must lurch about and tell people how much I love them when sober. I guess the lesson here is that I should be drunk more frequently.


message 10: by Erin *Proud Book Hoarder* (last edited Sep 29, 2016 06:24AM) (new)

Erin *Proud Book Hoarder* mark wrote: " I guess the lesson here is that I should be drunk more frequently. "

I become more confident, carefree, and outgoing. I guess I need to get drunk more too.

What good influences us Goodreaders are for each other - so inspiring!


message 11: by mark (new) - rated it 2 stars

mark monday it has quite a few hateable moments, especially in those last chapters. glad the review amused you!


message 12: by Ebster (new)

Ebster Davis I feel educated now. So I don't have to read it, right?


message 13: by mark (new) - rated it 2 stars

mark monday it is my policy to read these sorts of books just so that others don't have to. that's also why I watch certain reality programs. I am all about altruistically giving back to the world.


Kelly (and the Book Boar) This might be your best review ever.


message 15: by Cecily (new)

Cecily h, the perils of being known as The Reader - not that I've been lumbered by anything like this, but I have had a couple of not-quite-mediocre books I've felt obliged to read.

Nevertheless, I'm glad your company is doing well enough for you to be hiring.

mark wrote: "I've been told that I came across as alert and articulate when drunk, and yet sometimes appear drunk in social settings where I haven't had a single drink. curious!"

Ha! A kind of Schrodinger's drunk?


message 16: by Leo (new) - rated it 1 star

Leo Walsh I've read a lot of Rand. When I was like 14, I thought she'd shown me the light. But by the time I was 18, she made me laugh. But unintentionally, because I was laughing at her sophomoric philosophy. Especially in her later books.

And then last year, I got inspired to read "Atlas Shrugged." It was, hands down, the most awful book I ever read. Her "heroes" would be villains in any other book. They have no conscience. Things are set up so the "heroes" -- often uneducated -- have created world-altering invention entirely on their own -- which is NOT how things happen in the real world where breakthroughs are advanced via lab teams. And they do evil things for selfish reasons. Like stealing relief shipments being shipped to a disaster zone. And blowing up oil wells. Or threatening government officials with death in order to build a railroad....

Which, in the real world, was built with government money and land grants.

If you want a good laugh, read it. It'll make the next time your Libertarian friend praises Rand as the best writer


Deyanne My views have definitely changed regarding reading Ayn Rand as a teenager and then as an adult. She definitely fell from grace in my reading life.


message 18: by Alexa (new)

Alexa It is a far, far nobler thing that you do, than I will ever do (i.e. read any more Ayn Rand). You deserve all our praise for your sacrifice and altruism. Ayn Rand would have you shot. (This young woman clearly has some self-examination to face - that an Ayn Rand lover would be working for a non-profit in the first place?)


message 19: by Justine (new)

Justine lol Alexa:)


message 20: by mark (new) - rated it 2 stars

mark monday Kelly (and the Book Boar) wrote: "This might be your best review ever."

well thank you!


Cecily wrote: "Nevertheless, I'm glad your company is doing well enough for you to be hiring...

Ha! A kind of Schrodinger's drunk? ..."


that's perfect!

I'm glad about that too. finally! we've been in scarcity mode for decades. fortunately all the fund-raising and expansion ideas that my boss has been working on for years have finally to come to fruition.


Leo wrote: "I've read a lot of Rand. When I was like 14, I thought she'd shown me the light..."

my condolences and I'm glad you got past that!

also, I have to say that it was actually shocking to learn that Atlas Shrugged includes theft of relief supplies for a disaster zone... by the heroes! Ayn Rand can still somehow surprise me, I suppose.


Alexa wrote: "(This young woman clearly has some self-examination to face - that an Ayn Rand lover would be working for a non-profit in the first place?) ..."

I am excited to hear what she has to say about this particular um I guess duality in her nature.


message 21: by carol. (new)

carol. So... does she still work there?


message 22: by mark (new) - rated it 2 stars

mark monday she's out sick/working from home today! it is like she somehow telepathically realized I was returning her book to her today and would be curious about her thoughts on Rand, and so she headed for the hills.


message 23: by carol. (new)

carol. Strange that she isn't at work, showing her hard-working support for the man that hired her. ;)


message 24: by Mary (new)

Mary Regan Dear mark monday, Thank you for your concise send up of AR, which I completely concur with. Do you know serious followers of hers have formed communities that VERY much have the feel of religion about them? My cuz and his wife, who normally my hubby and I quite like, go to a week-long conference in the summer and weekends throughout the year. We literally avoid the subject like folks avoided politics and religion in the old days, i.e., when I was growing up.
P.S. I follow your reviews and always enjoy them. This one more than most. Thanks!


message 25: by mark (new) - rated it 2 stars

mark monday Mary, thank you for your kind words. and I did not actually know that and that's... weird and disturbing. it would be a must-avoid topic of conversation for me too. yikes.

thanks for following as well!


message 26: by Jaidee (new)

Jaidee mark monday....great review...you drunkard ;)


message 27: by mark (new) - rated it 2 stars

mark monday more of a stoner than a drinker but sometimes booze issues a siren call that is hard to resist!


message 28: by Conor (new)

Conor I've never read any of Ayn Rand's stuff but I've played Bioshock which explores similar concepts while also allowing you to shoot/magically electrocute/ incinerate zombie monsters.


message 29: by mark (new) - rated it 2 stars

mark monday sounds like the perfect setting to contemplate Rand's philosophy!


message 30: by Paula (new) - rated it 1 star

Paula ϟ Amazing review! Such an unbearable book. What's the update on your report back to the original lender? hahaha.


message 31: by mark (new) - rated it 2 stars

mark monday thanks! we never got around to discussing. she seemed nervous about my thoughts on it when I returned it to her, maybe due to my sardonic expression and the "well, there were parts that I actually liked, which surprised me" ... so I gave her break and left it at that. don't want to de-motivate my staff!


message 32: by Lata (new)

Lata Great review--I've never read any Rand and don't think I could stomach it. Altruism is a good thing in my mind.


message 33: by mark (new) - rated it 2 stars

mark monday Rand would hate both of us! glad you enjoyed the review.


message 34: by William (last edited Oct 26, 2017 05:04AM) (new) - rated it 1 star

William Terrific review. Well done!

Any Rand jungle capitalist.
GREED is truly the most terrible challenge of our times, and capitalism is its tool, its means to power and more greed.

Greed is a (contagious) mental illness, an unfillable hole, a hunger that denies justice, a brutal expression of broken egos.

Greed is having a million times as much as the poor and still feeling you don't have enough.

Greed consumes the earth without respite, and is a cancer on humanity.

Greed destroys us and our children and their future.

Greed is death.


message 35: by mark (new) - rated it 2 stars

mark monday I agree!


message 36: by Patrick (new)

Patrick You have the most entertaining reviews ever.


message 37: by mark (new) - rated it 2 stars

mark monday well thank you Patrick!


message 39: by mark (new) - rated it 2 stars

mark monday hello Charlotte. hope you are well!


Reading is my Jam Is My Lol best review ever. Given that 6 different (US) republican politicians quoted Rand in 2017 (YouTube it, I can’t make this sh*t up)...whelp I think that says it all! Great review Mark, liked all the non review input!


William “The modern conservative is engaged in one of man’s oldest exercises in moral philosophy: that is the search for a superior moral justification for selfishness.”
- John Kenneth Galbraith

or, simply "I've got mine, so f'ck you!"


Thank you for the review!


message 42: by mark (new) - rated it 2 stars

mark monday William wrote: "or, simply "I've got mine, so f'ck you!..."

exactly



Danielle wrote: "Lol best review ever. Given that 6 different (US) republican politicians quoted Rand in 2017 (YouTube it, I can’t make this sh*t up)...whelp I think that says it all! Great review Mark, liked all t..."

ugh, I didn't know that. but why am I even surprised.


Patricia Pirrotta Precisely how I felt about this book. Started off with Ayn Rand baggage as I started it, decided to let that go and then came the last two chapters 🤮. The last even worse than its penultimate. Never saw Fountainhead the movie but in the book, Patricia Neal’s lust for Gary Cooper is the result of his raping her 🤮🤮. Thinking a little 🍆envy going on with ol’ Ayn.


message 44: by mark (new) - rated it 2 stars

mark monday fortunately that is not in the movie! the scene in the film, if I'm recalling it correctly, is more of a ravishing than a rape - one where Patricia Neal is signalling No but meaning Yes (typical old school Hollywood).

Jesus, Ayn Rand, why?


message 45: by William (last edited Feb 02, 2018 03:09AM) (new) - rated it 1 star

William mark wrote: "Jesus, Ayn Rand, why? ."

Answer: She was badly damaged and traumatised in childhood, and probably again, and again, and again, by assh'le men (most likely) and the Hollywood system.

“Why Do I Love My Abuser?" by National Domestic Violence Hotline


National Domestic Violence Hotline
PO Box 161810
Austin, Texas 78716
Office Line: 512-453-8117


message 46: by Aneudy (new) - added it

Aneudy Espinal This was a lot of fun to read!


message 47: by mark (new) - rated it 2 stars

mark monday glad you enjoyed it, Aneudy!


Sara the Librarian yes but what about the pork bun woman!?!?!?!?


William Just read your review again. Truly Awesome!


message 50: by mark (new) - rated it 2 stars

mark monday Sara wrote: "yes but what about the pork bun woman!?!?!?!?"

please enjoy:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GcmKe...


William wrote: "Just read your review again. Truly Awesome!"

thank you William!


« previous 1
back to top