Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Five Brothers

Rate this book
One woman learns the secrets of the five Jaeger brothers.

On the other side of town, in the dark glades, under the rain…

Macon is the oldest. Thirty-one. Ex-Marine. I don’t think I’ve ever seen him smile.

Army is twenty-eight. A single dad with the most beautiful green eyes. He has no idea who he is, if not a Jaeger brother.

Iron will be in prison soon. You’d never think it to meet him. He’s a nice guy, actually. But he can’t stop reacting to everything.

Dallas is the one I hate. Twenty-one, cruel, and selfish. He takes and then throws away whatever’s left.

And Trace is mine. Or he was for about two seconds. No one can tame him for long.

Not that I ever wanted to. It was fun, but now I need to go home. Back to my side of the tracks. Away from the swamps and these men. To my parents’ big house. On my clean street. Where I’m never dirty or messy or hot. And I will. I’ll leave first thing tomorrow morning. I just want to crash on the couch tonight.

Their house is dark and quiet, everyone else is asleep. Except for one. He sees me crying and comes at me from behind. I let him wrap his arms around my body and hold me tightly. His breath is on my neck, his fingers are in my hair, and he doesn’t stop there.

I don’t think it was Trace.

560 pages, Paperback

First published July 30, 2024

About the author

Penelope Douglas

40 books92.8k followers
Penelope Douglas is a New York Times, USA Today, and Wall Street Journal bestselling author. Their books have been translated into nineteen languages and include The Fall Away Series, The Devil’s Night Series, and the stand-alones, Misconduct, Punk 57, Birthday Girl, Credence, and Tryst Six Venom. Please look for The Hellbent Series, coming next.

They live in New England with their husband and daughter.

Would you like to join the reader group? ---> https://www.facebook.com/groups/16198...

Looking for News?
Text DOUGLAS to 603-519-3800 to be alerted when new releases are live!
Website: www.penelopedouglasauthor.com
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/PenelopeDoug...
Twitter: www.twitter.com/PenDouglas
Pinterest: http://www.pinterest.com/penelopedoug...
Amazon: http://amzn.to/1A8hUBX
Instagram: www.instagram.com/penelope.douglas

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
7,859 (34%)
4 stars
8,043 (35%)
3 stars
4,645 (20%)
2 stars
1,458 (6%)
1 star
604 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 2,914 reviews
Profile Image for Penelope Douglas.
Author 40 books92.8k followers
Shelved as 'finished-writing'
July 30, 2024
𝐀𝐯𝐚𝐢𝐥𝐚𝐛𝐥𝐞 𝐍𝐨𝐰!
Thanks so much to everyone who's already read!



Amazon US---> https://amzn.to/47f4jy4

𝗢𝗻𝗲 𝗹𝗶𝗸𝗲𝘀 𝗵𝗲𝗿, 𝗼𝗻𝗲 𝘄𝗮𝗻𝘁𝘀 𝗵𝗲𝗿, 𝗼𝗻𝗲 𝗵𝗮𝘁𝗲𝘀 𝗵𝗲𝗿.
𝗢𝗻𝗲 𝗹𝗼𝘃𝗲𝘀 𝘁𝗼 𝗹𝗼𝗼𝗸 𝗮𝘁 𝗵𝗲𝗿, 𝗮𝗻𝗱 𝗼𝗻𝗲 𝗻𝗲𝘃𝗲𝗿 𝗱𝗼𝗲𝘀.

B&N https://bit.ly/40wGPlp
iBooks https://apple.co/3FVw4PT
KOBO https://bit.ly/3QwIpPz
BAM https://bit.ly/3MGknk6
Audible https://adbl.co/3SxEQub




Pinterest https://bit.ly/3YuDG6J
Spotify https://spoti.fi/3Wt7ptU

*FIVE BROTHERS is a standalone romance in the Tryst Six Venom world suitable for readers 18+.
Profile Image for ❥ KAT ❥ Kitty Kats Crazy About Books.
2,415 reviews9,971 followers
August 9, 2024
piZap
'F𝐈V𝐄 𝐁R𝐎T𝐇E𝐑S' Is a full length standalone romance book by author Penelope Douglas. Spoken in 'multiple POV's.'

This was the one book I’d been anticipating since I’d seen it getting pimped all over the place, eagerly awaiting release day.

Then I dived in..

I loved these brothers
Each unique in their own ways
And the one girl who was their glue without them even realising it.

The girl who fell for the boy from the wrong side of the tracks.

This kick starts off with Krisjen & Trace Jaeger kind of having a thing but not, within a blink of an eye what they did have was over before the ink on the page had even dried. Krisjen is from the right side of town, flash houses, flash cars, flash clothes, but she's at a loose end in her life, and doesn't really know what to do with herself. Highschool is over with and all her friends have gone off to their respective Universities.

She's always felt at home on the other side of the bay, especially at the Jaegers house where it feels more like a home than where she lives.

But both homes are full of their own dramas.

One night she has a sexual encounter with one of the brothers, being late she doesn't see which brother it was but she wants more and can't get that one encounter out of her mind, like Liv the reader is also playing the who was it game.

Email ಇ Twitter ಇ Instagram ಇ Blog ಇ Facebook ಇ Amazon 
ಇ Pinterest 
Profile Image for Ri ♡ .
414 reviews1,373 followers
September 1, 2024
“This could be it. The Tryst Six motto. A reminder that time is the most valuable commodity and no one can buy more of it. We can try, but the clock ticks and it never stops. It never slows.”


Five Brothers is not what I expected. It surpassed my expectations if you ask me, because this story is different from what Penelope Douglas usually writes. It's unhinged, it's heartbreaking, it's sad but also damn entertaining. There is not a single dull moment and I felt a wild ride of emotions throughout this book. I am amazed the way Penelope delved in character's past to write their personalities, especially because there are multiple characters and povs and they all added nuances to the story in their own way.

“Doing what you have to in order to survive isn’t noble if your soul can’t survive you,”


The storyline at first wasn't that fascinating. I mean all I could understand was that a Jaeger brother had sex with krisjen but since she didn't know who he was she tried to fuck them all to solve that mystery. It was funny at first and I already knew who that brother was. It was apparent with the way he was written. I liked the world building and it reminded me of Outer Banks with the Swamps vs Saints rivalry, a rich girl wanting to be with a boy from the poor and criminal side of the town. But what I liked the most was the found family trope. It was perfectly balanced with the mystery and romantic part of the story.


➸ Krisjen Conroy is a complicated character for me to fully understand. She acts stupid and childish and always ready to embarrass herself but she's also perceptive, supportive and compassionate. I liked her when she helped Jaeger brothers and her own siblings, and I liked her when she was protective of Macon, helping him in any manner she could.

“No one will remember me after I’m gone,” I say, “and I’ll never be someone kids learn about in school.”
I drop my eyes, heat covering my cheeks and my pulse racing painfully.
“I just want to love you.” All I can do is whisper. “That, I will do beautifully.”



➸ Macon is a complex character with an air of mystery and fear around him and that only made me love him more. He is the broody, quiet and intimidating Jaeger brother whose gaze is enough to threaten you to run for the hills. I guess I have a type and that's broken heroes. His story broke my heart. The eldest sibling with burdens of the world, the man who wants simplicity but can't have it because he was forced to live for others his whole life and was exploited many times. I cried reading his povs because his story is really heartbreaking. He only deserves the best. He is written by PD but he's not a red flag so you can only imagine how hot he is. His indifference, control and scary nature hides his pain and burden from the world but he couldn't hide himself from Krisjen. She saw him behind his façade and helped him heal.

“I hate you seeing me like this,” he says barely above a whisper.
I give him a half smile and tell him again, “You can let one person see you like this.” And I rest my cheek against his shoulder. “I have a steel stomach.”



➸ Army is the sweet and kind brother. The one who keeps their family united. He is stable and a little emotional and I loved to see the real him. He is a single dad and that's another plus point because they are my kryptonite.

“Maybe I just needed to remember how to see the beauty in things. The little things.” He stares at me. “You make things pretty, Krisjen.”



➸ Iron is the troublemaker, the rebel of Jaeger family who wants to be seen and loved but gets ignored because he's a middle child. I want him to have his own story and a chance to redeem himself because he has so much potential.

“I want to get in the car with you and drive to a different fucking view tonight. I want to drive fast enough that the sun never comes up.”



➸ Trace is the one I hated at first but then he grew on me slowly with his protective and playful nature. He was the only one who always protected Krisjen and took her side and that's just so sweet.

“Nothing is better than the wrong thing. Wrong things kill our insides.”



➸ Dallas is the hardest one to like. I still don't know what I think of him. He's well... something else. He is scary but also annoying and I don't understand his obsession with hating Krisjen.

“I didn’t hate these things, because these things are profound. Horrible. Tragic. But profound. And profound is beautiful, because it changes us.”



: ̗̀➛ The romance is a slow-burn if you consider the fact that Krisjen only chose one brother and she took her sweet time with every brother. The romance with the man she fell for and the one she chose was done so beautifully. I liked the tension between him and Krisjen. They had more emotional intimacy and vulnerability between them and that only made me like their relationship.

“I’ll always see you,” I say, but my voice is gravelly with tears. “Even when I close my eyes.”


The smut scenes were hot and immaculate and it's PD we are talking about, and don't worry nothing questionable happened.

I liked the epilogue and though there are no loose ends in the end but I still felt the ending was rushed. I would've loved a few more chapters from Macon's pov and how he is dealing with everything. A sweet little bonus epilogue with all their found family.

I am hoping for Dallas to have his own book with Callum Ames. It's giving enemies to lovers vibes with angst and heartbreaks and I am here for it. And it could be the first MM romance by Penelope Douglas and I can't wait to know what she has to offer us!


💌 To my bestie giul

I had an amazing time reading this book with you. Our buddy read was spontaneous and crazy and unhinged and I loved making theories with you. It was so much fun screaming in our dms, crying for Macon and swooning over Jaeger brothers together. I can't wait to have many more crazy buddy reads with you in future. Ily 💙

I definitely recommend this book. And if you want mystery, unhinged drama, sexy smutty scenes, broken characters, entertainment. Then you've find your perfect book!

—————
jokes on me for thinking this was some unhinged shit but this book actually made me cry 😭 Macon deserves the world ❤️‍🩹 anyway rtc!
—————
buddy reading this with bestie giul bcs curiosity is a bitch
Profile Image for currently being delulu .
427 reviews172 followers
August 14, 2024
… andddd back to a two star 🙃

I had a long beautiful review typed up and ready to go but it got deleted so here is a jumbled mess⬇️




*Krisjen* without sounding like I’m slut shaming her bc I’m not but in the kindest way possible please learn to go love your self

I didn’t connect to keisjen or her choices and actions granted she is 18 I just don’t think she was mature or fully equipped to handle some of the things in this book and tbh she let ppl take advantage of her a little too much the brothers included like girl stand up I understand Penelope was going for a softer heroine but she kinda came off like an airhead



I honestly don’t fully agree w who she ended up w in the end bc it really felt like bc of her daddy issues why she was so obsessed w him and I don’t feel a genuine connection maybe if she didn’t immediately start trying to throw her self at him in one of their first scenes when they’re working in the garage together and instead she was just trying to be there for him or make him laugh since she knew he struggled w depression and suicidal thoughts…. Idk kinda weird that her first instinct to make him feel better is for her to drop her cloths and tell him she fantasize abt him when she was in high school…. The way I cringed l when he walked away…


Tbh the found family aspect I think is handled better in credence then it was here I didn’t feel any genuine connection w her & the brothers tbh it felt like a lot of the time they were using her not really caring abt her it felt kinda icky when ur in Krisjens pov and she’s like “ Omg their all so wonderful and I want to help allll of them”

And in some of their povs their like “ damn she’s a hot piece” I was honestly surprised that Dallas was the only one who didn’t really think of her sexually and saw her a beautiful light and that’s why he hated her partly tbh he’s still a dick to her w intention of using her later on but hey Dallas is a see what you get kind of character so I’m not surprised how horrible he is to the ppl in his life


And tbh Penelope’s books are a hit or miss for me lately I thought this was gonna be a 5 star guaranteed

I’m not sure why pen felt the need to make her sleep w the other brothers when it honestly felt weird af when She did that she was just being used by them this girl felt desperate for love and for somebody to love her that I kinda felt like at one point she’d take anybody and never say no to them it was sad to me not sexually liberating like I think Penelope intended I don’t like the way Krisjen let the brothers walk over her yeah a few times she can snipe back but for the most part she kinda let’s everyone just take advantage of her



Macon my one true love in this book the way I adore this man and all that he is his pov made me sob ngl the way he was so obvious depressed and was struggling uhg I love him


And tbh Krisjen needed to get off her high horse girl you slept w 3 of his brothers one in the back of a cop car that macon watched you two have sex on the dash cam soooo do you have room to talk

The man was struggling to pay bills raising his 5 younger siblings and clinically depressed bc he had to sell him self to provide for his family yes was I grossed out and unhappy that he slept w her mother in the past however did I understand why he did it and why he didn’t tell her yes … bc he’s obviously ashamed and I’m pretty sure he blocked most of that out bc again the man was depressed


Tbh I kinda laughed when it came out bc the plot was going all over the place at that point that it was getting ridiculous I couldn’t keep up with the constant change of pace in the scenes

Like I said this book in way is very depressing & kinda has a icky feel to it I was left at the end not really rooting for them to be together I just wanted Macon to be happy and get help and I wanted Krisjen to find her self and learn you can be there for people without letting them take advantage of your kindness


Details & safety info

I don’t really remember anyone but trace sleeping w other ppl she sleeps w 3 of them Macon doesn’t sleep w anyone


The brothers she slept w are

Trace “ past not in the book”

Iron “ he’s going to jail so she gives him a going away present” 🤪

Army “ single dad who feels like no one sees him honestly kinda liked him but don’t like the way he treats Aracely hope they do not end up together”


Macon is our winner tbh it’s pretty obvious from the start who was on the couch w her I’m not sure why This is supposed to be a mystery through out the book …. Anyone can put it together in five seconds
Profile Image for Christy.
4,238 reviews35.1k followers
July 6, 2024
4 stars

After reading Tryst Six Venom, I was curious about the Jaeger brothers. When I heard they were getting their own book, I knew I wanted to read it. This book had Penelope Douglas’s signature captivating writing and effortless storytelling. This reminded me of Credence in some ways, but so much better (at least for me).

Krisjen is one of Liv and Clay’s friends. It’s her first year out of high school and she isn’t sure what she’s doing with her life. She’s from the ‘right side’ of town but has a boatload of family drama, making her life increasingly difficult. At the start of the book, she has a thing with Trace Jaeger, but that ends rather quickly.

Even still, she finds herself spending lots of time with the Jaegers at the Bay. She feels more herself there then she does at home. There is an encounter with a brother early on in the story and it leaves you questioning and wondering who it was and how things will turn out.

I liked all the brothers in their own way. I was rooting for either Macon or Iron, but Army was great as well. Dallas and Trace weren’t my favorites (at least not for Kristjen) and I was happy with how things turned out. I hope we get many more Jaeger books in the future!

This was one of those books that captivated me from the start. Once I started, I didn’t want to put it down. The only reason it took me around a week to read is because life was busy and it’s a long one. Otherwise, I would have devoured it quickly! Penelope Douglas fans- grab this one! You’ll love it.

6 reviews
August 2, 2024
this book was truly fucking awful.. like why is an 18 year old a therapist to these grown men?? and then the plot??? the sex in the cop car?? i read this book because penelope douglas was one of the authors that reintroduced me to reading but man do i regret it.


the book truly pissed me off…

and then all the random heartfelt conversations at weird times??

don’t get me wrong i love a reverse harem but this?? they are treating her so horribly and she’s just going from room to room fucking them?? on top of that i didn’t feel any sexual tension between the characters

this review is all over the place and that’s because i editing it once i think of something else that made me mad
Profile Image for Mareeva.
382 reviews8,925 followers
August 6, 2024
4 stars

Technically, my "keeping it in the fam" shelf is reserved for incest only, but homegirl really did keep it all IN ONE FAM, so I guess it fits.

🛑SPOILERS🛑

I've realised the one thing that always works for me by Penelope Douglas is the fake reverse harem trope. I say fake because this isn't really a reverse harem, she fucks everyone but ends up with one guy, like in Credence. Still a win in my book but lowkey misleading.

I did not expect this to hit me right in the feels. Y'all know I love depressed fictional men😔
Macon's POV was tearing me apart sometimes. I was desperate for him to feel any tiny shred of happiness and the heroine delivered, unlike his brothers. Literally how did they not see Macon's depression until she had to spell it out? The scene where she starts comparing his symptoms to that of his deceased mother (who committed suicide) almost broke me.

I really appreciated that Macon's depression didn't just magically evaporate into thin air the moment he got with the heroine. Did she push him in the right direction? Yes. Did she play a big factor in his good days? Yes. But she didn't cure his depression by existing.

All in all, Macon deserved the world and more. The rest of the boys? Debatable.

- Except for Iron. It's self-explanatory. Who doesn't like a gentle, caring, violent, felon? I can't believe Penelope sent my second favourite boy to prison and reduced him to basically no page time.
I also just realised his name is literally Iron. Why? Although that could be asked about the names of 90% of the characters in this book.

- Dallas was annoying but he was also unintentionally funny sometimes. The heroine be happily living her life and he'd pop in with the most uncalled for comments.

I toss a marshmallow in the air and catch it in my mouth in front of the baby. He giggles.
“It’s easy to catch shit with a big mouth,” Dallas gripes


Thank you, Dallas, for that mesmerising observation💀

- I didn't care about Army and I don't think I fully understood what his deal was, but I also felt bad for him.

- I don't even wonna talk about Trace. I think his relationship with the heroine had the potential to become much deeper platonically. The author was hinting at it, but I didn't believe it.

Overall, I am just bummed that this was almost 600 pages and some things still felt unresolved by the end of the book.

1) So did she just.....never break up with Army or what😭 I really think he was developing feelings for her but then she randomly got with Macon and never addressed it?

2) Why was there no reunion scene with Iron tf?

If I could describe this book, I would say if Outer Banks and Boys of Tommen series had a smutty baby, this would be it. Set up your expectations accordingly tho cause this is still just a raunchy fake reverse harem.
Profile Image for L.A..
607 reviews250 followers
August 1, 2024
If you love The Outsiders Greasers vs Socials, or Outer Banks Pogues vs Kooks, then you will appreciate the drama in Five Brothers....Saints vs Swamps. Society separates into haves and have nots. and it is a clear line drawn in this book, separated by railroad tracks. The Five Brothers live in a dilapidated house on the bay in St. Carmen, Florida, and they are known as the Swamp people.
Fascinated with their lifestyle is Krisjen living in high society, prim, and proper etiquette, but loves these brothers. She is known as one of the Saints. Her family is wealthy, but struggling with her parents' divorce. What she has discovered is, it doesn't matter how much money you have if you are not happy together.
The life of the Swamps is freedom, determination and banding together. Even if they don't have material things, they have each other. Their parents died a few years ago, while Macon was only 23 years old and in the military, but returned to take care of his siblings.
The steamy romance is explicit and intense. With the characters building and growing throughout, there is never a dull moment with its action packed drama. It has been a hit or miss with many readers, but this Outsider fan loved it.
Thank you NetGalley and Berkley Publishing Group for this incredible ARC in exchange for my honest review.
Profile Image for giulsxx.
126 reviews73 followers
August 18, 2024
4★
”This could be it.
The Tryst Six motto. A reminder that time is the most valuable commodity and no one can buy more of it. We can try, but the clock ticks and it never stops. It never slows.

this wasn’t what i expected AT ALL.
one sees “five brothers” and the mind does all the maths knowing it’s pd we’re talking about, you know?
‼️WRONG‼️
this book actually had a plot and an interesting one too! it also deals with heavy matters and i suggest to read the TWs and i also recommend to read Tryst Six Venom first. i haven’t and the first few pages of this book were a little confusing.

plot
krisjen is a saint but has a thing for the Jaeger brothers. one night she fucks one of them but who?👀🤭🤪

krisjen is a weird character, or at least i have weird feelings about her. she’s kinda stupid sometimes and acts childishly. but other times, she’s really likable. she’s not my fav but she’s a good fmc taking into account she’s been written by pd.

”Maybe I just needed to remember how to see the beauty in things. The little things.” He stares at me. “You make things pretty, Krisjen.”


macon is THE MAN. omg this man made me cry but also feel other things. he doesn’t have ONE red flag, can you believe it???? he’s like a family man, a ex-marine, the eldest of the family and the one who carries the burden. he’s the scary brother and the one who boss around everyone. from now on i’ll eat icecrem in a cup🙂‍↕️

”He’s okay. He’s always okay. I go to the window again, watching him head back into the garage, dressed in jeans and a gray T-shirt. Just like my first memory of him. Needles prick my throat. Macon is my first memory ever. Not my mother or my dad. Macon.”


army is so sweet and thoughtful. but he also has other qualities the cops car scene *coughing*🥵. he’s a single dad and besides taking care of his son dex, he also helps macon with the family businesses. he’s not the scary brother.

I take her in my arms, then notice the white dress she’s wearing. Sleeveless and ending at mid-thigh, it has straps across her chest and back, showing slivers of skin. Her hair is soaking wet now, but she feels just as good. And slowly, I start to spin, holding her eyes the whole time. “What are you doing?” she asks, stumbling as she tries to keep up. “It’s our first date.” We’re dancing.


trace is the free spirit and the playboy of the family but i adored how he was protective of krisjen. how he treated her and always said good things about her.

“I think it takes everyone some time to figure out what they want and what they’re worth. Some people spend years settling for something, because it’s better than nothing, before one day we finally realize that it’s actually not. Nothing is better than the wrong thing.”


iron is the brother who always gets into fights. the last one costed him 4 years in prison. so we know very little of iron but he has a big heart like his brothers.

Iron takes my face. “I want to get in the car with you and drive to a different fucking view tonight. I want to drive fast enough that the sun never comes up.”


dallas, last but not least! he clearly has issues but i’m too curious about him. he claims to hate krisjen but it’s so much more than that.

”Without ever writing a word, I was a poet. I saw beauty in the unlikely places that scared my parents. In abandoned train tracks. The foster home hells where my friends lived. In house fires, motorcycle crashes, and the destruction in the wake of a storm. In living too hard and dying too young. In tears. In bruises. In abandonment. I didn’t hate these things, because these things are profound. Horrible. Tragic. But profound. And profound is beautiful, because it changes us.”


overall, i really would recommend this book. the smut is good as always since it’s pd smut. but the story is captivating and the mystery about the brother who fucked krisjen is so interesting and there are multiple povs!
the ending felt a little bit rushed, it seems like pd couldn’t wait to wrap it up, but i would’ve loved to read more about some things which were a huge part of the plot.

to my beloved ri:
tysm for reading this with me. i had sm fun and i think i loved this book this much also bc i read it with you. i loved making theories with you and no shoker here agreeing on so many things! it was so funny ranting and screaming about it and since we have sm in common and agree on so many things, we should definitely do it again💘 ily

At some point I really need to learn that men are just not worth the trouble.

“I think that’s why I liked you so much,” I tell her in a low voice. “You seem the same whether you’re around people or not. You never put yourself away.”

Because beauty is in the small things and character is in the flaws, and learning that fact can’t be taught or told.

“It seems I’ve always been missing someone.”

“I guess I’ll forget the things I love, too.” I go back to sanding. “Life takes you over like that. You lose yourself. Who you were when you were five was the real you. Before everything started to kill you.”

I don’t know what it is about her, but I don’t even need to sleep with her. I just really like seeing her in the morning.

“I used to want to do certain things with my life when I was younger,” I tell them, “but now I don’t know what the hell I want, except just to be in love with someone and love our family. To be with people I care about and have great days and a football team living in our house, helping other people make memories and making sure we all smile ten times more than we cry.”

All I know is that I feel it, too, sometimes. People make life hard. Even the ones who love us bring pressure and obligation, and I’m no exception. We’re all culprits of making someone else’s life difficult.

“There will be hard days, Macon. There will be more days like this. When it really hurts to stand up. To face people.” I want to touch him—his hand, something—but I hold back. “But there will be days that no one can touch,” I whisper. “There will be days when you’ll be the strongest one in the room, and they wouldn’t have made it through without you. There will be kids and road trips and hunkering down for hurricanes with our beer and movies and food fights and babies and ice cream in coffee cups.” His head turns just a little, and I can see his eyes. “And early mornings in warm beds,” I say, “when the rain and wind chimes are going and you’re holding her, and these feelings right now are so far away and you can’t stop kissing her. You’ll love being alive.”

“Where is everybody?” She sighs. “They were rushing off when I got up,” she tells me. “It’s supposed to rain later, so they wanted to get all the jobs done before it starts.” They wanted to get all the jobs done … Jesus fucking Christ. Are they all trying to make me proud or something?

“The only thing I need a man to protect me from is a life sentence. He can clean up the evidence when I’m done.”

“I was told I was smart,” I tell him. “That I would take on the world and everyone would know who I was. I would be someone great, and no one would be outside my sphere of influence.” Adults tell every kid they’re significant. We want to believe it. “But the thing is …” I go on, “I’m not unique. I was never that smart. I’ll never be an astronaut, or the captain of a ship, or a professor of biology or philosophy. I’m not a good athlete, and I’m fine seeing mountains and operas and Alaska just on TV.” None of that is what I wanted out of life. I want none of what I was taught to want. “No one will remember me after I’m gone,” I say, “and I’ll never be someone kids learn about in school.” I drop my eyes, heat covering my cheeks and my pulse racing painfully. “I just want to love you.” All I can do is whisper. “That, I will do beautifully.”

Dallas and Iron are one side of the same coin. There’s a detachment inside of them. If they make up their mind it needs to be done, then there is no choice. Army and Trace are the other side of that coin. Loyal, but their conscience takes up a lot of room inside them. Liv is a mixture of both. Things need to be done, and she accepts that she’ll feel like shit about it sometimes. I’m not sure which one I am yet. I always felt like shit hurting someone, but I felt the same watching TV.

Just one more day. I can stay for one more day.
Profile Image for Sophia Panella.
58 reviews6,443 followers
September 2, 2024
Devoured this in 2 days. PD stays as one of my favorite authors EVERRRR (wanting to re-read Devil’s Night rn). This is such a classic PD book with the plot and kind of characters, but I honestly loved it🫣 Call me Sophia Jaeger from now on.
Profile Image for fiz.
52 reviews9 followers
July 31, 2024
what the fuck ass was i even reading…
August 31, 2024
Saint versus Swamp!



The following ratings are out of 5:
Romance: 💙❤️💚💜🖤
Steam: 🔥🔥🔥🔥
Story/Plot: 📕📗📘📙📔
World building: 🌏🌍🌏🌎🌎
Character development: 😊😄😘😍🥰

The heroine: Krisjen - She lives on the wealthy side of the tracks in St. Carmen. Though her parents are going through a nasty divorce and their father has all the money until everything is settled. Meanwhile her mom is trying to force her to marry a rich lawyer named Jerome Watson, though she is basically selling Krisjen to him to secure the lifestyle she wants to live. Krisjen told her mother to just marry him, but she doesn’t want to have more children, so she is forcing Krisjen to do it. Krisjen is eighteen and out of high school, all her friends left for college, and she doesn’t know what to do with herself. She has a younger Brother named Marshall and a five-year-old sister named Paisleigh, whom she loves and wants to stay near rather than leaving them on their own with her mother.

The Heroes: Macon, Army, Iron, Dallas, Trace - The Jaeger brothers. They live in a dilapidated mansion on the bay, the poor part of St. Carmen. The people from the wrong side of the tracks in St. Carmen are known as the Swamp. They own and operate a family landscaping and pool cleaning business.
Macon - The oldest of the brothers at 31 years old. He was in the military when his parents died eight years ago, and he got out to take care of his five younger siblings and has been angry at the world ever since. He runs their business from home and rarely crosses to the other side of the tracks.
Army - He is twenty-eight years old and a single father of a one-year-old son Dex. He is the boss of their business that everyone sees.
Iron - He is really a good guy, but he has a habit of getting in trouble with the law. He was convicted of his last offense and will soon have to go to jail for 3 ½ years.
Dallas - He hates the Saints (the wealthy people of St. Carmen) with a passion. He is twenty-one and lives for instant gratification.
Trace - He is twenty and a nice guy, but lives like a twenty-year-old. He loves to party, and he loves all females. He and Krisjen were hooking up for the last six months, but she wasn’t the only one.

The Story: Krisjen is in a time in her life when things are supposed to change, but she is also deciding what she wants out of life and for her future. She grew up wealthy, in a world that is clean and pretty on the outside but often dirty and ugly on the inside. While her friends on the other side of town seem to live a life that is happier and freer, despite the fact that many of them have issues. Such as Iron, who has to go to prison for the next 42 months, and Macon who doesn’t open up to his family and seems to carry the weight of the world on his shoulders.

I loved this book from the start. I read some other reviews which compared it Credence another Penelope Douglas book about a family with issues and the girl that changes everything for them. That was a book that a lot of people either loved or hated. I loved it and agreed that this one has a lot in common with that book. Especially the fact that the men are all super-sexy and they all have the kind of personalities that you just want to know. Whether it be the dark and broody or the happy and life of the party types, they all seem to be the kinds of guys that you just want to know all of their secrets and spend time with. Each of the guys was so great in their own way. You could tell that Krisjen had feelings for each of the guys and they her, but she was looking for something and didn’t quite know how to find it.

The plot had me from the start and kept me interested the entire way through. The world building was on point, you could almost feel the sultry Florida heat, the rain. I loved the descriptions of Krisjen’s clean and bright Florida mansion, like a Palm Beach Estate, and the Jaeger’s neglected mansion in the swamplands slowly being taken back by nature. The character development was great as well, I had clear pictures of them in my head, and they all grew and changed throughout the story. The intimate scenes were sizzling hot, and I loved the way the characters all felt for each other and for family.

I voluntarily read & reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts & opinions are my own.

Blog|Goodreads|Facebook|Instagram|Pinterest|BookBub
Profile Image for Iqra.
519 reviews4,500 followers
Want to read
July 21, 2023
Forget this book they need to release motel before I grow old and grey or else 🔪
Profile Image for Shelby.
279 reviews1,525 followers
August 13, 2024
2⭐️ maybe 3?? I dnno.

This is Credence 2.00 meets outerbanks vibes with a Kaleb from Timu.

And is it good? No. Did I binge it in 2 days. Yes.

Unfortunately Five Brothers follows the same weak formula as every other why choose, despite NOT being one. The FMC picks a guy at the end 😅 but it’s still a bunch of bird brain men all obsessed with one girl and I’ve not got a scooby why.

A reread of Tryst Six Venom isn’t necessary. I soon caught up. Five Brothers for sure can be read a standalone.

And the start was promising. Krisjen is a Saint, from the rich side of town and best friends with Clay from TSV. Her parents are divorcing, and to sustain their lifestyle and keep a roof over their heads, Krisjens mother is proposing an arranged marriage for her. But Krisjen has been seeing Trace Jaeger (Liv’s brother from TSV) for the past 6 months, a Swamp. I thought that would be the direction of the story. She falls in love with the poor, whilst knowing the rich guy is best to secure her and her families future.

And I dnno wtf happened but it tailspinned the hell out. It was CHAOS. I had no idea what was going on half the time yet I COMPLETELY understood how it would end and what PD was trying to do.

They wanted another Credence but Credence is a unicorn. It worked because of the setting, and the characters. I got why the men were obsessed with her, why she did what she did with them 🤣 why she picked one at the end.

In Five Brothers, who knows why??? I didn’t understand any of the characters by the end, their motivations or what made them different. They all sounded the same, the dialogue was WEIRD, the interactions WEIRD 👀 and don’t even get me started on the spice.

The hose pipe. The cop car 🤔 THE HOOVER 😰 All that sex?? How does this girl not have a severe UTI? BV? My PH balance could never 😤 How did her vagina not fall off.
And who is that sexually confident at 18 years old? This book required me to suspend all and any belief. It was utterly ridiculous and shouldn’t be read and rated seriously.

Also would like to know why PD is so obsessed with the whole ‘them v us’, stupid games, traditions, pranks *you can’t take our men*, etc ITS SO DONE 😩

My excuse for finishing it? I was on holiday with nothing better to do at the beach 🤣


Profile Image for vee!.
127 reviews3,780 followers
Want to read
July 22, 2023
the way i thought we‘d never get books for olivia‘s brothers.. and here we are ❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹
Profile Image for Haley Jean.
274 reviews3,012 followers
August 30, 2024
depressed? wanna k!ll yourself? apparently 18 y/o pu$$y is the solution!!

penelope douglas continues to force these strange age gaps and make sexual tension out of thin AIR with barely any plot
also, im convinced Krisjen is a bot. no personality, no interests .. besides seducing these grown men, wanting to me “owned” by one, and already acting like a psuedo-mother to her younger siblings
and then once she finally *picks* which brother (thank god she chose correctly unlike credence), she is SO quick to discuss getting pregnant like DAMN

i kept thinking that she felt like a victim. let teens be TEENS. 😭 the story could have functioned the exact same with the same age gap shifted. krisjen could have easily been 23/24.

was i entertained? yes. did i enjoy it? debatable.
i just don’t think me and PD agree on what is “romantic” or sexy .. i miss punk 57 HAHA
Profile Image for Morgan.
507 reviews102 followers
April 15, 2024
Star rating: ★★★☆☆
Spice rating: 4 🥵🔥
State condition: Disappointed

Thank you to Penelope Douglas and Berkley for an e-ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Oof… this was one of my most anticipated reads for this year because we haven’t gotten a Pen Doug book in 2 years, and I was clamoring at the bit for this one. However, this whole book just wasn’t my favorite.

Without going into any real specifics, because there is still a hot minute before this one releases and I don’t want to spoil anything, the individuals that loved Pen’s infamous book ‘Credence’ for everything that it was, they will absolutely eat this book UP. However, if you disliked ‘Credence’ for everything that it was (or are like me and it was just meh for you) I feel like those feelings will most likely be the same in regards to this book….

For more bookish content and discussions, please follow my bookstagram💕

https://www.instagram.com/lovinmyshelf/
Profile Image for Melanie (mells_view).
1,812 reviews377 followers
July 31, 2024
“But I see you. Even when I close my eyes, I see you.”

Penelope Douglas has an absolute grip on writing books that reel you in with the taboo tropes, while stealthily providing that impactful emotional love story mixed with a found family trope that will grip your entire heart and squeeze.. and squeeze.. and then give it a metaphorical forehead kiss to soothe all the aches and angst you just survived while reading. Sigh. There are so many things I expected going into this book with Krisjen and the Jaeger family, and my expectations were met, but they were also blasted into outer space because this book was beyond all expectation.

If you couldn’t tell I’m keeping this vague, but it’s very much intentional. I’m giving you the feelings I felt, but that’s it. Experience the journey of Five Brothers through your own perspective. At its base, it’s about a girl who lives on the “right side” of the tracks essentially finding her place with five brothers on the “wrong side” of the tracks. It’s about home, family (born and found), and love in so many forms.

I know Pen thrives best under low—no pressure, so I’m just going to gently put it out into the universe that I’d read any number of books taking place in this world. You know, just in case they get the wild idea to write more Saint and Swamp “track crossing” or just ANYTHING involving this character set. I volunteer as tribute to be in the Jaeger/Sanoa Bay fan support club.

IG: https://www.instagram.com/reel/C8VWcX...
IG: https://www.instagram.com/p/C-C_3SUx1...
TikTok - https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZPRoQbtyV/
TikTok - https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZPRoCeJXE/
TikTok - https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZPRoQGJMJ/

TW/CW (these will contain spoilers): discussions of parental suicide, suicidal ideation, untreated mental health crisis, parental abandonment, physical assaults from a previous partner/others, CNC play

**I want to make note that this is labeled as standalone, and CAN be read that way, but in my honest opinion to get proper background on the Jaeger family and the vibe/history of the town I’d suggest reading Tryst Six Venom first.**

AVAILABLE NOW!
*ARC
Profile Image for Kim.
742 reviews1,877 followers
August 28, 2024
Seriously, what a terrible day to have eyes.

First of all, I need a shelf called “Extremely Stupid Names”. I thought Den Of Vipers (which I also did not like) was the biggest offender but sadly, a new player has entered the game. I will spare you the details because they are THE worst but there are at least 6 characters in here where you think “ugh, this name is the worst, this is rock bottom” and then that happened 5 more times and it always got worse. Every time one was mentioned it took me right out of the story. Safe to say I never really managed to get into it (the cop car scene, what?).

And can we stop already with the barely legal children living the lives of experienced porn stars? I used to be such a fan of this author but now it’s just getting extremely weird how young all the characters always are, especially the girls. You’d think at some point the “I just turned 18 two hours ago, let’s bang” thing gets, well, old. But apparently, no.
Profile Image for Llakshmi.
511 reviews450 followers
August 6, 2024
it’s difficult for me to put into words how this book made me feel.

did I love it? Did I find it okay? was it too messy? were there too many men? did I like who she ended up with? did I want her to end up with one of them? or did I want her to finally leave them all in the end and realise she’s better off? was there too many POVs? was her character strong? or was the author gaslighting us into thinking the fmc is strong when in fact she was treated like a toy among the guys who supposedly loved her? Didn’t he need more povs?

These were all thoughts that went through my head until the end. the rating speaks for itself, my overall aura and mood after finishing five brothers was happy and satisfied so it’s safe to say I liked the book.

I don’t want to even waste my time writing my feelings about each of the guys because frankly they didn’t matter. It was all the fmc, she carried the book. that’s all
Profile Image for Katie Friday.
200 reviews8 followers
August 1, 2024
Right off the bat: if you haven’t read Tryst Six Venom. You are at an extreme disadvantage. This book never bothers to introduce you to anyone, drops you off in the middle and never explains anything. It’s a complete lie that you don’t have to have read it.

I absolutely hated this. This book is over 500 pages and has exactly zero character development, plot or sense.
It’s not even spicy, it’s cringy.
In lieu of character development, backstory’s, motivations, literally anything this book relies on 1980’s style stereotypes of rich kids versus poor kids.

Krisjen (I can’t even with that name) is and remains a complete mystery to me. I never understood her for a second, she gets into fights with the boys then just suddenly takes her top off. Nothing that she does or says makes any sense. Shes whoever the scene needs her to be. Her motivation to stay and hang out with these boys never makes sense. I couldn’t make heads or tails of her kinky sexual stuff or her plan at the end of the book.
Also… really HOW DOES SHE NOT KNOW WHICH ONE SHE SLEPT WITH!?!?!?!?!? Whoever you think it is, you’re right. It’s painfully obvious from the beginning.
It’s so fucking stupid.

There’s no plot to this book, random things are picked up and dropped off like they didn’t happen. Between pages 400-408, there’s a random hundreds years old secret buried treasure they have to protect. What the fuck was that?
They use spikes to drive someone off the road, who then crashes in a ditch, that’s never brought up again.

Ooooof… I could do a Ted talk on this…

Stay thoughts:
It cannot be overstated that apropos of nothing, and no build up what so ever Krisjen will take her top off and probably have sex with someone for no reason.

This book couldn’t decide its stance on sluts. Vis a vis: good or bad? Everyone in this book slut shames Krisjen, as she makes her way through all (some? Who cares) of the brothers. No one more than the five brothers, they constantly call her a whore, slut, then give her money after she does something bizarre like take them food then gets sexual with a hose FOR NO REASON. Then in their pov chapters they all talk about what a ray of sunshine she is but the second she walks into the room and they are like “go back to fucking my brother ya slut!”

Honestly I laughed a lot, I think that’s why this is 2 stars. None of the emotional beats hit. It was like the movie The Room, but in book form.
Profile Image for Katerina Saltanovska.
76 reviews1 follower
August 1, 2024
2 stars ⭐️⭐️

I was really looking forward to this book, but I didn’t like it as much as I expected. Everything was just too similar to Credence, while I did like reading Credence, cause it was something unique and forbidden at that time, Five Brothers just seemed like too much were the same. It was disappointing.

Krisjen felt like a degradation to all female characters in Pen’s book. She’s eighteen and doesn’t plan to go to college. She has no hobbies. No plans for the future. Just a desire to be loved and owned by a good man. I was not a fan of her at all. And don’t get me started on the all sexual escapades. It was so messed up. I suspected from the begging who her love interest might be and we found out about 50-60% in the book first hints to that.

Overall, the book felt like there was no plot at all, but it dragged on for quite awhile. Also I didn’t see any relationship built. It was spicy, messy and dark. So be aware before reading.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 2,914 reviews

Join the discussion

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.